Jump to content

SubtleKnife

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by SubtleKnife

  1. SubtleKnife
    That's what I meant when I said "Of course, in Ive's day this may very well be treatable - or even optional". And with their technology, there certainly would be a lot more similarities between the siblings than would occur naturally. hehehe, if it's good enough, those are forgiveable. But remember, science fiction or not, it's still the author's job to convince the readers to suspend disbelief.
  2. SubtleKnife
    I'm not a geneticist, but I read a couple of those registered cases and at the present this situation is only possible as the result of (a) genetic defect(s).These sets of twins are monozygotic, which we generally call "identical twins", but thanks to a chromosomal abnormality they're not identical. Of course, in Ive's day this may very well be treatable - or even optional, I wouldn't want to tell the author what his world is like - but unless the doctors reverse the gender of one of them, at the best you could call them "monozygotic with discordant sex twins", which doesn't sound nearly as good as identical... PS don't take too long studying this, get to writing that next chapter!
  3. SubtleKnife
    Hi there,I very much enjoyed it, thank you. However, I don't believe you can have identical twins that are a boy and a girl. Even if technology advanced to create a boy and a girl from the same genetic material, by definition they wouldn't be identical, would they?
×
×
  • Create New...