I am aware that he's French-Canadian and that it is a completely different culture. That was a joke.
I did say that my distate for him was irrational and pretty much unfounded. I should probably reread EW as well, to either find concrete evidence for the way I feel (for myself really, not to argue this further) or change my opinion.
If I had known that there would be a sequel, focusing on Luc (and Matt), I probably wouldn't have interpreted EW as a competition of sorts for Scott's affections. At the end of EW, I thought Josh had basically "won" (a supportive lover guiding him through recovery) and Luc had "lost" (well, he had his family, but he essentially lost Scott and perhaps the one thing that made him really happy, his sklls as a pianist.) Which made me empathize more with Luc and apparently WAY less with Josh.
I realize now that regardless of HTLGI's existence, it was so silly of me to have viewed such a complex story as this in such a simple manner.
And I'll just go ahead and apologize to Duncan for insulting a character he has painstakingly created for us.