Jump to content

Eric's Blog

  • entries
    131
  • comments
    385
  • views
    49,707

Well, I've recently upgraded both my laptop and tablet to Windows 8.1 (well, 8.1 update 1 but as we all know it's a service pack so nice try Microsoft) and I'm finding that I'm liking the revision that they did. It brought back more of the desktop experience which is what a lot of people like and missed with the original Windows 8. So to me Microsoft, with the latest update, turned it into Windows 7 with a brand new start menu interface.

 

Now don't get me wrong I am by no means a Microsoft fanboy but I will give props where props are due. Over the past couple of years I've used all three desktop operating systems (Linux, Windows and OSX) and two major mobile systems (Android and iOS) and have found pros and cons with them all to which this blog is about (I'm feeling super geeky today haha). So this blog is going to be all about the desktop operating systems:

 

Windows Pros:

  • Most common operating system used and allows a seamless transition in terms of knowing how to use it, from one computer to another IF they're using the same version of Windows
  • Going from desktop system to a mix of cloud and desktop (one drive)
  • Most software and peripherals are designed with Microsoft in mind
  • Heavily used in large corporate environments, medical fields and government areas
  • Heavy integration now with Office 365 and Windows to make it seamless
  • Many MANY games are designed to be used with Windows
  • Has its own App store for windows compatible software

Windows Cons:

  • Unless you have a good Security Software system you're more susceptible to viruses
  • Does not play well with other operating systems unless you know how to 'make it work' (heh Tim Gunn reference)
  • Media store (like iTunes, Amazon or eMusic) is just plain horrible. Even naming it zune just shows how bad it is (and for those who don't know or even heard of Zune, it was a media player that Microsoft made to compete with the iPod and its now dead but the name lives on UGH!)
  • Heavy and professional music editing software, while able to work on Windows doesn't play well at times and many professionals prefer to use Apple for that reason
  • Internet explorer, one of the worst internet browsers to exist in my opinion, and should have never been allowed to exist (if you have it I implore you to use Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox!)
  • Has its own App store for windows compatible software running in the Metro/Start Menu interface

Apple Pros:

  • A very stable system needing very little attention and extremely user friendly
  • At the forefront with a lot of new technology and ideas
  • While security software should be installed, it's not as susceptible to viruses like windows is
  • Excellent and pretty much designed for editing media such as movies, pictures and music
  • Safari proves to be a pretty good contender for a built in web browser
  • Excellent built in media player with access to iTunes (one of the most popular places to buy and purchase media)
  • Uses Sandbox to prevent non-signed applications from being installed unless it is directed by the user
  • Has its own App store for apple compatible software which can be installed on any apple computer that is linked with your apple ID

Apple Cons:

  • Uses a lot of peripheral technology which makes a lot of things incompatible with other operating systems until they are released (e.g. Thunderbolt, lightning connector, 30pin designed only for iPods and tablets
  • Not a lot of software compatibility between the two and cannot run windows applications without either having a OSX compatible release or running or running Bootcamp or inside a virtual machine
  • Until apple started using Intel, it was nearly impossible to get any windows applications used thanks to the PowerPC processor they used instead
  • Apple's version of office leaves much to be desired with when compared to Microsoft Office
  • Heavy integration with iCloud with provides Windows users and Android users a portion of the power that it provides those with out iOS devices or OSX
  • Uses it ownership of iTunes to market the latest and nicest apps on the Apple App store
  • Cannot easily change your apple ID
  • Not a lot of games are compatible with Apple but most gaming companies are fixing this

Linux Pros

  • Follows the Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) doctrine which allows users with the heavy tech knowledge to go in to the actual operating system, tweak it to their needs or improve it
  • Uses a community based ideal to allow people from all over the world to use and modify it easily
  • Easier to set up for server applications (many companies use enterprise versions of Linux to run websites, servers and backbone infrastructure to allow communication between all operating systems using the SAMBA suite (open source implementation of SMB protocols)
  • Just like OSX, it is not as susceptible to viruses and malware but still like I mentioned its always good to have a good security software system enabled
  • There is a variety of 'flavors' to use for the interface. Everything from graphic oriented to minimalist design
  • Some companies (like Dell and HP) offer it as an alternative to Windows and offer support with it as well
  • Offers app stores on some Linux systems that contain the FOSS

Linux Cons

  • Most software used by OSX and Microsoft are not compatible with Linux unless use an emulator like WINE and even then it might not work
  • Updates and security fixes depend on the different Linux flavor you use and how often it can be updated
  • Some companies have chosen the path to offer two types of their Linux product, one that is entirely FOSS and the other that costs money due to proprietary drivers that cost money to include to play various media, drivers and other items.
  • Some streaming media companies do not support Linux (Netflix is one example) while some do (Hulu and Pandora are the two that I know of)
  • Cross-compatibility with documents and media sometimes result in either corruption or messed up formatting.
  • Integrated media sales platforms are either non-existent or provide a very limited selection (best one to use is either amazon or eMusic)

So as you can see there are many pros and cons to the various desktop systems while my lists provide a brief glimpse into the pros and cons, of them it is by no means a comprehensive list and I could be wrong on some points so if I am or you have something to add, please feel free to add your comments in this blog. I also want to add that the next blog will deal with Android, iOS and Windows mobile operating systems which should be just as interesting if your technosavvy.

 

The last thing I add, because there are people who feel strongly about the systems individually, I do not want flame wars appearing in the comments. Any that do will be deleted and reported per the GA rules. One final point if you have questions or need help with something with any of the systems listed above please let me know by contacting me at phantom.586@outlook.com and I'll help you best I can. I do this for a living as a band 1 technician for a very big company (which means help desk and troubleshooting).

 

Cheers and thanks!

 

Eric aka Phantom

 

 

**edit to add: Thanks to an anonomyous reader for pointing out errors and edits that I missed :) **

  • Like 3

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

Zombie

Posted

thanks Eric - useful summary :)

Mann Ramblings

Posted

Nicely done without getting into a "this system rules and all other suck" tirade. Thanks!

nostic

Posted

I just got my desktop Windows 8.1 and I felt truly cheated, thanks for the post, I feel a lot better :D

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...