Very interesting beginning, the end of Chapter 1 is going to make me come back for more, (it also took me a while to figure out exactly what happened, well done).
I thought right from the start the story was brillant. The subtle idea of the 'perfect match' came out from the very first paragraph. Attempting to find the symmetry and where everything on the table should be positioned.
The character development kept me quite interested and by slowing weaving everyone together made/makes me want to continue to read more. The semi-love triangle, but more like intertangled love of friends, with Brad, Nicky and Donny is quite intruging and I want to know where it will go! I love Beth's character, her tenacity and williness to stick with Donny, which I'm sure will become tested as the story continues. I also find Brad's father and Brad's situation/dyanmic between the two scary but complex and surely will lead to much much more. The character of Brad's father is so well constructed and by making him a government official adds a lot (perhaps more so with recent events...not quite the same but parallels can be drawn).
I'm really looking forward to seeing where this goes, and glad that you've got the next chapter coming out soon. Great Beginning!