I would've fallen for Luke just sayyin. I know this story is foreshadowing and setting up Aaron to be the bad guy but honestly I think there's nothing wrong with any of the way Aaron has been behaving so far. In fact, so far he's the good guy. Rory needs to use his words to communicate properly and have an actual conversation for once. Just put everything on the table and see how people will respond because if he doesn't, Aaron is going to turn into the bad guy due to a misunderstanding just like how Luke, Eddie, and now Dave had.