One might argue that both J and S are right in their analysis, but neither will help create a situation that allows three men - specifically these three men, in this part of the USofA - to actually share a real life, rather than a fairy tale-one in some sort of "happy end"/"they lived happily ever after"-fashion. If the author, after the splendid job he did with this story, yet opts for one, he does himself short, or so I feel...If not, the promise suggested in this chapter is, for all three if them, a decision. Does that mean that - Miss Daisy's wisdom and wishes notwithstanding - this is a tragedy after all?