Jump to content
    Riley Jericho
  • Author
  • 5,644 Words
  • 15,811 Views
  • 42 Comments
Stories posted in this category are works of fiction. Names, places, characters, events, and incidents are created by the authors' imaginations or are used fictitiously. Any resemblances to actual persons (living or dead), organizations, companies, events, or locales are entirely coincidental.
Note: While authors are asked to place warnings on their stories for some moderated content, everyone has different thresholds, and it is your responsibility as a reader to avoid stories or stop reading if something bothers you. 

An English Teen, Circumcised in the USA - 84. Visitors

An English Teen, Circumcised in the USA

by Riley Jericho

Visitors

Luke managed no more than a dry croak of a greeting as Todd offered up the nearby beaker, and he sucked at the straw, feeling the cooling liquid slip down his inflamed throat. Finally, he lay his head back on the pillow.

Todd settled his bulk onto the edge of the bed. "Your mom and dad are outside with the docs. They said you were awake and that it would be cool just to pop in to leave these." Todd didn’t seem worried that it was probably going to be a one-sided conversation and lifted a large bag of grapes that he’d rested on the bed when he’d sat down. "Mase is outside, too, with Si, but I couldn't just piss off without seeing how you were doing, could I? The others all wanted to come down as well, but I said I'd best check in on you first."

The others? School friends?

Luke tried to force a smile, but his face didn't easily go there. He hoped Todd would understand, though it was typical of him that he'd have everyone organized. Luke was also suddenly glad he was there; another face that felt normal. He finally gathered his voice, and croaked, "What day…?"

"Day? Today, you mean? It's Friday, of course." Todd frowned, then re-gathered his banter as his face creased into an easy laugh. He popped one of his own grapes into his mouth and chewed. "School's done, though. Hell, you don't honestly think they'd let me out just for an asshole like you, do you! Jeez—you're not that much of a celebrity! We brought Si down from school for your folks. I mean, you might not believe it, but while you’ve been living it up here for the week, the rest of us have had to work. And, in case you're worried, we saved all your assignments. You might look like crap, but you’re not getting away with it that easily!”

Friday? Four days since Monday? Luke struggled in his head to do even that simple math, though the time he’d been out of it could have been twice that long for all he knew. Todd had tried to sound jocular, but it was a little forced, and Luke could hear an awkwardness there.

“How’s…” He coughed. It was hard to speak and the back of his throat was still sore from the tube they’d taken out. He coughed again to clear the phlegm and gathered his voice. “How's...Ry...?”

The last he'd seen that day in the Alexis house, it had seemed Ryan had been knocked out cold. Now, even after so many days, it was really only the first time he'd visited the question of what had happened in that kitchen. Maybe his lack of curiosity had just been self-preservation, but now Todd's presence forced the issue to the fore.

Ryan? How was he? Where was he? How come Todd had come to visit, but not Ry?

Alarm bells were beginning to go off in Luke's head. Now that he started to dwell on it, he realized that nobody had mentioned Ryan, not even once in any of the muddled snippets of background conversation he'd overheard. Now, his stomach twisted, and he already was afraid of what was coming, what the answer was going to be to his questions as Todd’s face dropped, the smile with it. Todd's gaze flicked away, and he looked upset.

"Ry...?" Todd stuttered. Glancing backwards towards the door, he seemed to be unbalanced and searching for help. “I thought...they…they didn’t tell you?”

Maybe Todd had come to the bedside with the plan to be encouraging and supportive, but his face crumpled. Todd, who was always so strong. Todd, who’d been their natural leader though all the years Luke had been at the Academy. Todd, who’d always find a way to make it right, faltered in front of Luke and his eyes filled up.

“He's...I…he's gone, Luke.”

Gone? Where? The sickening, painful knot grew in Luke's stomach.

Todd's face twisted in a failing effort not to get emotional, and the grapes were left abandoned on the sheets. “The bastard killed both of them—and one of the cops, too.” He turned away and rubbed at his face, cursing under his breath.

Luke closed his eyes. He had no energy to acknowledge the cold hard truth of who Todd meant by, 'both of them'.

Gone? Dead?

It was hard enough just to know, but he had nothing left in him, no energy or emotion to be able to figure out when or how Ry might have been killed—or make sense of the loss. Maybe it was all just a bad dream, he mused, and he would wake up shortly? Perhaps shutting Todd out would make it go away?

He heard the door to the room open.

“Todd? Are you okay?” From their voices, Luke's mum and dad had hurried in. Todd’s weight shifted from the bed.

"What's wrong?" Luke heard the worried tones of Todd’s brother, Mason.

“I’m really sorry, Mrs. Summers. I didn’t know you hadn't told him about Ryan. I didn’t know what to say—” Even with his eyes shut, Luke could almost see the tears wetting Todd's face, running down cheeks pinched in pain.

“It’s okay, son.” Geoff's voice this time. “Maybe it was best coming from you, anyway. Ryan was your friend, too.”

Ryan was your friend, too. It seemed a surreal dream as it went dark again and Luke drifted away.

He slept again, waking some hours later though it was impossible to tell what time it was as the blinds were drawn. Evening maybe?

Slowly, as reluctant as treacle, he came to the surface once more. He'd had the dream again—a dark nightmare—and was damp with sweat as he broke into the light. He had no idea what he'd been shouting as he broke out of it, but he'd been petrified.

It had been a dream that he'd first had after the birthday party at Stacey's house, and in that dream—that nightmare—he'd found himself trapped in a bathroom that appeared to have a window installed in the door. And beyond the door, seen partially through the window, was something sinister, malignant, raging.

It had only been a bad dream at the time, quickly forgotten, but now, as it repeated itself, it seemed that that same face sought to crush and destroy him for real. In a swirling confusion of mixed, dark emotions, the very real Alexis had, not many days earlier, twisted against him, bellowing unknown words. Just as in the nightmare, the bulging eyes in the pool had judged and condemned him as they'd sunk deeper.

It was a vision he knew would no longer be easily shoved aside.

His dad was over by the window, and, next to the bed, his mum was wearing the same clothes as when Todd had visited, so Luke guessed it was the same day. Leaning over from where she’d been reading a book in a comfortable chair, she rubbed his hair gently.

"It's okay, I'm here...it's just a bad dream...you're safe now."

As the fear receded, he turned his head imperceptibly towards the cup and straw as he tried to figure out what was real in his life and what was nightmare.

"Something to drink?" She put the book down, and he accepted the straw, sucking deeply at it.

“The doctor said you could try a little food if you’re hungry. I’ll go let them know, if you want."

He shook his head as she started to rise.

She tried again. "Simon's here..."

As if on cue, Simon pushed into Luke's line of sight, and it didn't help Luke that his brother started crying as he threw himself—albeit carefully—onto the bed.

With all four of them there and together again, maybe it should have been something to celebrate, but Luke could find neither the energy nor the courage to face the question of why he was alive while so many others were dead. He let Simon chatter on inanely, complaining in frustration at first that their mum and dad had made him go to school on Thursday and Friday, and then the next moment passing message after message from school friends. Luke listened with half an ear.

The time passed. A day? Two? It was hard to tell between the sleeps and regular doctor's examinations. He was still sleeping a lot, though the tally of waking hours was creeping up now. Each time he awoke, he felt a little stronger, taking some food at last—some soothing soup that tickled down his throat in the small spoonfuls his mum fed him.

He began to talk more, responding better to the doctors as they continued to prod. The pain in his shoulder remained a dull ache, and was impossible to lie on, but his head had cleared. The pounding headaches were passing, and he was able to take stock more easily. His insides seemed to kick into gear, too, though his need to take a crap sometime during the night had ended up with his behind the curtain with a male nurse and a bed pan. Even so, he couldn’t help being hungry and was eating more frequently, but after that demeaning experience, he vowed the bed pan would never happen again!

As far as he knew, after Todd, there were no other visitors. Either his mum was keeping them away, or they didn't care. There was no mention of Elliott and Estela, and nobody said anything more about Ryan, either—which was fine, because he didn’t really want to talk about that anyway: So, it was a surprise when he heard the voice of Grace Skerrit at the door to his hospital room.

The better Luke got, the more uncomfortable he became, and during the previous couple of days, finding a good position for his aching shoulder was becoming increasingly difficult. The doctors were pulling him off some of his stronger meds, and he could feel it. Either he lay flat on his back, or, as he was at that particular moment, on his side, resting on his good arm. That way, he faced away from the door and towards the window. He didn't really have the energy to be sociable, even with Grace, so he kept his eyes closed and feigned sleep. It wasn't hard.

"We're about ready to be off." Grace's voice was a whisper and it seemed she assumed Luke was asleep. "We want to make the most of the light Sunday traffic, but we couldn't leave just without saying goodbye, and Toby wanted to see Simon, too."

"Grace, I'm really sorry we haven't been there to help you pack up," Lucy said.

"Don't be silly." Grace sounded surprised. "You've had more than enough to deal with! How is he, by the way?"

"A lot better now, thank God. You know, we didn’t even know if he'd make it at first, but they say he should make a good recovery, now."

"Well, that's great news!" It was the voice of Marcus Daniels, and behind closed eyes Luke surmised that 'ready to be off' meant the three of them were heading down to Florida.

"Ken Milton said it's been tough for the school, though…especially Ryan’s class," Daniels continued. "Ryan was popular and…we all saw a bright future ahead for him."

Ryan. There was what felt like a long silence, and Luke wondered what they were thinking.

"We've packed the final bits into the U-Haul this morning," Grace said. She sounded like she was trying to change to a better subject. "It's down in the parking lot. How we ever got it all in, I've no idea."

"It's got a trailer, too!" This was Toby’s voice, and he sounded quite excited by the trip ahead. "Marcus is driving it. Mom's following in her car."

"I sold mine to a colleague," Daniels said. "But at least we'll have something to get around in until we get settled."

"Time for a drink before the three of you head off?" Geoff asked. There was a pause during which Luke assumed they were looking at him, as his dad added, "Oh, don't worry about him, he's fast asleep."

"Simon and I can stay here while you go, if you want," Toby said.

"Can you bring me back a Coke?" Simon asked

Marcus said, “We’ll get you something, too, Toby, to drink on the way.”

The four adults left the room shortly thereafter, and Simon and Toby moved towards the sofa by the window—the one that could be turned into a bed. From the position he was resting in, his head partially buried in his pillow, Luke watched them from between his eyelashes. It was the first time he'd seen the two of them together since the summer. In the last few weeks at school, Toby had looked as distant and brooding as Simon had, but now he appeared relaxed—upbeat, even—as he rested a bag at his feet and took a seat.

"So how long will it take?" Simon asked, sitting too.

"To Orlando? About seven or eight hours I think. We'll stop and eat on the way. Marcus wants to do it all today if we can."

"To his parents?"

"Yep—until we can get a place of our own. They've got a big house, and even a pool! Pity I never got to show you on Google Earth."

“What about Gizmo?”

“He’s in the back of mom’s car in a cage.” Toby snickered. “To steal one of your expressions…he’s pissing mad!”

Despite his circumstances, Luke struggled not to smile.

“So, when do you start your new school?”

“Next Monday, a week from now. Mom’ll take me in to enroll this week sometime, though it’s all been set up, Marcus says. He’s going to be teaching in the same place.”

“Art?”

Toby snickered. “No, French, asshole!” There was a pause, then, “By the way, this is for you.”

“Me?” Simon said.

Wanting to see what they were referring to, Luke tweaked open his eyes once more to spot Toby reach for the bag on the floor. Toby drew out a flat object that was wrapped in brown paper. Looking smug, he passed it to Simon. “Go on—open it.”

Simon studied the package.

“Come on…open it, then!”

Setting it on his knee, Simon appeared to pull at a piece of binding tape and then folded the paper aside. Luke could see immediately that it was some kind of frame.

“I got it re-framed last week for you,” Toby said, his mouth creasing into a grin. “It’s taken ages to go through all my studio and pack up what I wanted to keep. It's a bummer I can't take the mural in my room, but we took some pictures of that anyway for my portfolio.”

“It’s the boat, isn’t it?” Simon took the flat object. From its shape, Luke had guessed it was a picture, and now he knew which one.

Toby sobered and looked down at the brown paper package that now rested on Simon’s knee. “I’ve been working on it all week. After what I did, it was the least I could do. I…I know nothing can put that right, but….” He trailed off.

Simon undid the package, folding back the paper until the picture became visible on his knee. Luke knew that it had to be the one he’d picked up from the ground at school after the fire. Somehow, Toby must have got it back.

Simon didn’t react for some time. “It’s good,” he finally said. He pointed at something. “That’s not you, is it.”

“It needed another person in the boat, and…no…it’s not me.” Toby sighed. “I don’t know who it is, but I painted him in for you. Maybe it was a bit stupid, but…anyway, whoever it is, he’s a lucky bastard!”

“Who knows.” Simon wasn’t particularly effusive. “Anyway, thanks for this. It’s nice.”

If Toby was expecting more, it wasn’t there, so his gaze flicked towards the bed. "Is he really going to be okay?"

Simon turned his head to study Luke, too. "I hope so. The doctors say so, anyway."

“Is it true he took a bullet?”

Luke knew his eyes were obscured enough that they couldn’t tell he was watching and listening. He saw Simon nod, and say, “In the shoulder. They say it chipped a bone, but missed the important bits.”

“That’s good, isn’t?" Toby said, still staring. "Has he said anything about what happened?”

Simon shook his head.

Toby seemed pensive. After a few moments, he said, “You’re lucky.”

“Lucky? Him, you mean?”

“No…you.” Toby sounded wistful. Luke could see that Toby was still looking in his direction, so he kept his eyes closed and remained still as he followed the conversation.

“I…well I always wished I’d had a brother.” Toby said. He paused, then snickered. “Even a sister would have been better than nothing!”

Simon did laugh this time. “You? A sister? Can you even imagine it!?”

“Okay, maybe not…” Toby chuckled. He added, “Did he ever know about us?”

It was an unexpected question and Luke’s ears perked up further, wondering what Simon would say now about the relationship he wasn’t meant to know anything about.

“Of course he knew. He always knew.” said Simon. Luke could hear the shrug in his brother’s steady voice. Maybe it wasn’t hard to confess now that Toby was leaving for good. Simon added, “He knew everything.”

“Everything?” There was a pause, then, “Did he know about what happened? What I did to you…when I hurt you? Did you tell him?”

Luke studied the pair through his half-closed eyes. This was the closest he’d ever got to knowing what had happened between Simon and his boyfriend. He wondered what ‘when I hurt you’ meant.

Some of the confidence dropped out of Simon’s tone. “No. I wanted to tell him, and I probably should have, but…”

“But what?”

“I tried, but he…. The time never seemed right.”

“But—” Toby sounded pained.

“It doesn’t matter now,” Simon interrupted. He wrapped up the picture, and leaned it against the sofa. “I’m past all that. I don’t want to talk about it.”

Luke closed his eyes to retreat into darkness. He was shocked. Something had happened between Toby and Simon. Something that Toby was to blame for…and something that Simon had tried to tell Luke about, but that Luke hadn’t taken the time to listen to.

There was a light tapping at the door, and Luke was familiar enough now with the slight squeak of the handle to know that it was opened moments later, even though he couldn’t see that direction.

"Hello, Simon." The voice was soft and, with its complicated accent, all too familiar.

"Elliott?" Simon's tone carried a frown. "What are you—"

At the sound of Elliott’s voice, Luke warmed with a mixture of relief and pleasure. For the briefest of moments, all the joy he’d experienced at times when he and Elliott had been together came rushing in; the flirting fun and the the relish at knowing he was about to start dating a guy that really had his attention.

"I saw your mom and dad downstairs,” Elliott murmured to Simon. “They said he was asleep, but that you were here, and I could pop up to see..."

"Oh. Yes, I think he might be asleep, but..." Simon paused.

Luke’s delight was short lived. So much had gone wrong, was confusing. Behind tightly closed lids, he groaned silently at something he just didn't know how to face quite yet.

"...but you're welcome to stay a bit if you want," Simon continued.

"Thanks." Elliott closed the door behind himself.

"Come on, Toby. You said you wanted something to drink before you start off down to Orlando—"

"But I thought—" Toby sounded whiney.

"Come on...let's go." Simon's overriding voice and the turning of the squeaky handle placed him at the door.

"You might as well bring your stuff...we can still talk." He sounded determined, though whether it was to get Toby out of the room, or to force Luke to talk to Elliott, Luke didn't know. It appeared that Toby was placated as he shuffled out after Simon.

The door closed behind them, and moments later, Luke felt the movement of the hospital mattress as Elliott settled onto the bed, close enough that Luke could pick up that familiar aroma of aftershave. It brought with it too much emotion, and a tear trickled from Luke's eye. If he was hoping Elliott would continue to think he was asleep, he'd just blown that away. And anyway, pretending not to be awake now was just more deceit. What his hurting heart cried for was to reach up, hold onto Elliott and let it all out, but neither his head nor his aching frame would allow him that freedom

There was silence for long moments, then a soft voice. "Hey there...how ya doing?"

Luke turned on to his back and wiped his eyes with his good arm. His reply was husky. "Not good."

“I heard you had a pretty crap week…Mom and Dad say hi, by the way.” The light tone came with a hand that touched Luke’s face, brushing at the sliding tears. Luke couldn’t help jerking away at the touch. He carried far too much guilt for such easy, caring gestures. Awkwardly, he tried to sit up. With his eyes now open, Luke found himself being watched by somebody he liked, somebody he was glad was there—but he still didn’t know what to say to Elliott. He couldn't keep eye contact for long, but it was long enough to see the furrows of confusion creasing Elliott's brow.

"I saw your mom and dad downstairs," Elliott repeated. Uncertainty crept into his voice.

"I heard," Luke muttered. He lapsed into silence, staring at the white sheets, but only visualizing the blood and the grime of his own failings. His whole life was a failure, and everyone he touched got hurt.

Elliott tried again. “I got your message that you couldn’t make it to the airport, and I called a few times after dropping off Es—to your mobile and your home phone—but, there was never any answer. I came over to your place on Tuesday afternoon, but there was nobody there. I thought maybe you’d all gone on holiday or something. I…I wasn’t sure what to think.” Elliott sounded awkward.

“It wasn’t until the next day that I found out what had happened through Trish—your friend Kieran’s girlfriend. She asked if I’d heard anything from you. Hell…when I found out the details, it was a complete shock!” Elliott glanced around the hospital room and grimaced as he shook his head. “Then it was all over the papers, too.”

“The papers?” Luke frowned. Maybe he shouldn’t have been surprised, but he was. It felt like he knew less about what was going on than anybody! Elliott’s finger touched Luke’s hand—just a brief contact—though this time Luke didn’t pull away. He would have liked to have held a hand, but Elliott didn't offer it.

“I finally managed to get through to your mom on Thursday night,” Elliott said, “but she said I should leave it for a few days if I wanted to come visit. I left you messages, but—”

Elliott’s eyes strayed to the door. Maybe he was being careful. “I know they don’t know anything about us, so…well, I tried to be patient, but it was killing me not knowing how you were doing. It must have been awful... We've all been worried for you. Even Es..."

He tailed off as Luke continued to stare at the bedding, offering nothing back. Elliott may have texted, but even if he did know where his phone had ended up, he wasn’t sure what he would have said in reply. He’d had days to think about it, and could only come to one conclusion: he was a waste of space, a useless piece of crap—someone who'd cowered at the back of the room the day they put Ryan—his best friend—into a hang, and then watched the fun like all the rest of them. A guy who couldn't even find the time enough for his younger brother to see that something was badly wrong. Why the fuck would anyone want to be his friend, let alone his boyfriend?

"Sorry...you're probably not up to any of this,” Elliott murmured. “Maybe I should go...?" He made to stand, but Luke grabbed his wrist. Whatever else, he needed to explain.

“No…it’s okay, don’t go…it’s just me.”

Elliott settled again, though Luke knew he was giving mixed messages.

“Do you want to talk about it?” Elliott asked at last.

Luke's dry voice burst out before he could stop it. "I just don't know what's right anymore."

"I don't understand?"

"He'd still be alive if it wasn't for me."

Elliott frowned. “Come on-—you know that’s not true.”

“What would you know?”

Luke’s reply was abrupt, but Elliott didn’t react in a like manner. Instead, he said, “So tell me.”

"He was gay, okay..." Luke said. He hung his head as though it were a confession. "And I fucking killed him!"

"Ryan? Gay?” Elliott blinked in confusion. “I...I don't understand. You never said. And what do you mean you killed him? You're not making any sense. You didn’t do anything!”

“Fucking right I didn’t! I let them hang him!” Luke knew he wasn’t making any sense to Elliott, but it hardly mattered.

“So...you two were together?" Brushing aside what must have sounded like a madman, Elliott looked and sounded uneasy now. "Why didn't you tell me?"

"No, it wasn’t like that. I told you, I only just found out about him. He managed to get hold of my phone that day and saw the texts we’d been sending back and too.”

“Oh.” Some light of understanding crept into Elliott’s face. “He found out about us?”

“We had a fight, but then he turned out to be Damon.”

“What?”

Luke knew again that he wasn’t making any sense, and that Elliott had a right to look confused, but he had no energy just then to try to explain the whole thing about Damon Jamieson. Instead, he just said, “I went round to his place to try to sort it out—to talk to him. That was when I called you. It was then he told me he was gay, too.”

“So then what happened?”

Luke’s face reddened as they came to the crux of it. “We were only getting changed...to go swimming. I'd only just found out about him." He found himself babbling as it all blurted out. "He...he...wanted to be with me and I...I didn't know what to do when he— His father...I couldn't get out..."

Elliott froze and he flushed. "You were...having sex…and he caught you?"

"Of course we weren't! No! It wasn't like that!" Luke paused a beat and felt sick. Having sex? He might have well of been! He'd stood there in front of Ryan with a serious fucking erection, and now he felt cheap. And his discomfort at carrying that guilt obviously showed.

"So what was it like then?" Elliott muttered. The flush was spreading under his white tee. "What am I supposed to think?"

"I can only give you the truth," Luke said, trying not to get angry with either Elliott or himself. "There isn't anything else. I've known him forever and...and he wanted to be with me...like that…I didn't know what to think.”

“But you like him?” Elliott pushed. There was a pause as he must have realized that the verb tense was awkward.

“Of course I liked him,” Luke said, eventually. What was the point in denying it? “But I told him no. I told him I was with you. But then his father burst in. And now Ryan's fucking dead because of me."

Elliott looked relieved, though still cautious. "Okay, I believe you. Sorry. But you can't blame yourself for any of what happened. Come on...we can get past this." He took hold of Luke's fingers, maybe knowing he could quickly let go if there was movement at the door. There was a long pause as Luke studied the fingers that gently rubbed his own. It was only the second time that Elliott had ever touched him in a way that meant something. The first time had been seven days earlier—a week that had changed everything. He wanted more, but…he just didn’t deserve it.

"I can't," Luke said, He extracted his hand and the fingers slipped away. “Not just now. I need some time.”

“Time?” Elliott couldn’t hide the disappointment. He let his hand linger nearby on the bed. “I don’t—”

“It’s not you, honestly, it’s me.” Luke cringed at a phrase that had always felt like trite claptrap, but was actually how it was. “When I could have done something, I didn’t. I froze and I let him down. If I’d have done something, maybe I could have got the gun and stopped it. But I didn’t and now…now he’s dead because of me. And now I don’t know anything anymore.”

"Hey, come on,” Elliott persisted with a plaintive voice. “It wasn't your fault. You mustn't—"

“You weren’t there!” Luke’s anger stayed whatever Elliott was going to say next. “I need some time to sort things out—not about you, but about me. I always thought I was—” He stumbled over the idea that he’d always believed he was some kind of selfless, nice guy, and then pressed on. “I never thought I’d stand by and watch someone I cared about get hurt. I need to find myself.”

“What does that mean?” Elliott murmured. “What about us?”

Luke turned his eyes away. “There can’t be an ‘us’, not right now at least. If I can’t…” He shook his head painfully, unable to put it into words. “This is really something I need to find on my own. I’m sorry, but I need some time.”

Elliott’s face fell. “Don’t say that.” His voice was whisper soft. “Don’t push me away. We can deal with this together. Don’t wall yourself off.”

“I’m not like you.” Luke reached out and brushed against Elliott’s still hand, hoping to make it feel less like a rejection. “You’re strong and steady, I’m not. I failed him—twice. Probably a lot more than that…I don’t know. You can say I didn’t, but you didn’t see what happened. Ryan fought back, for himself, to be who he was. And he fought back for me...to give me a chance. He….”

The tears wouldn’t stay back as Luke finally let out the awful truth of his actions. “He… he told me to run and I did. I ran, and I left him to die. I’m… I’m not worth your time, Elliott. Find someone better.”

“Luke… I… you’re right, I wasn’t there. But you can’t judge yourself on that one moment.”

“I know—but Ryan cared more about me than himself. All I cared about was saving my own worthless...” Luke scrubbed at eyes that prickled with growing pain. “You can say it’s okay, but it’s not. For me it’s not. I need to be better. Not just for you, but for myself. I need to know that if…when I commit to…to you or anyone else, I won’t let them down. I can’t say that right now.”

The silence between them extended and Luke felt more of a shit than ever—made even worse when he finally looked up and saw a tear on Elliott’s face.

“Sorry.” Elliott seemed upset with himself more than anything…which actually made Luke feel worse to the point of almost saying ‘the heck with it, come here’!

“I understand, but I don’t…I don’t want to give up on you or us.” Elliott scrubbed away the wetness. ‘You’re the first person I’ve opened up to in a while…since…” He didn’t continue, but Luke got the picture—one that hung on the wall in the Carter’s dining room. Was he destined to always mess up people’s lives?

“Just give me some time.” It broke his already fragile heart, but when Luke looked inside himself, he didn’t like what he saw. Others might think he was a cool guy, a nice guy—the special kid who came from England, who said all the right things and went to a top-notch school. He’d always felt he was better than everyone else, but what Luke now saw in himself, he could barely tolerate. Being around Elliott, who always stood tall, knew who and what he was and wasn’t afraid to be real…it was too hard. It also wasn’t fair to Elliott. He had a right to be able to depend on his boyfriend, and Luke had learned the hard way that he wasn’t that person.

“Can we still be friends?”

Luke nodded, not trusting his voice.

Elliott stroked Luke’s hand one last time, then eased off the bed. “I’ll call you,” he said. With that he left the room.

Only then did Luke turn into the pillow and give in to the tears.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Thanks for reading this last chapter – a difficult and painful one for Luke.

I wrote a song this week. All I can say, is that if came by surprise, but I posted it here alongside my other stories! Maybe it's for Luke, or maybe it's for me…or even you. I hope you'll read 'Stand', and find out!

Riley

Copyright © 2016 Riley Jericho; All Rights Reserved.
  • Like 35
  • Love 1
  • Sad 5
  • Angry 2
Stories posted in this category are works of fiction. Names, places, characters, events, and incidents are created by the authors' imaginations or are used fictitiously. Any resemblances to actual persons (living or dead), organizations, companies, events, or locales are entirely coincidental.
Note: While authors are asked to place warnings on their stories for some moderated content, everyone has different thresholds, and it is your responsibility as a reader to avoid stories or stop reading if something bothers you. 
You are not currently following this author. Be sure to follow to keep up to date with new stories they post.

Recommended Comments

Chapter Comments



On 07/31/2016 01:39 AM, ephoebusbosch said:

I was half prepared for this. Half. Well...it's not like you didn't warn us well in advance <<in this extraordinary tale of life, love and loss>> Deep down I knew that you planned to kill him from the very beginning, and when those two shots echoed through the house while Luke was hiding, that pretty much settled it for me.

Luke blames himself. I know it's not his fault at all, Alexis was a crazy bastard and something like this was bound to happen sooner than later, but Luke's right in one thing: he's not like Elliott. He did leave Ryan "hanging" more than once. He's always been happy just standing by to see what happens. Hell, if I suspected that a friend of mine was going through something similar to Ryan, I'd be there. I'd hug him. I'd cheer him up. I'd try to help. I feel like Luke was never there to Ryan before apart from when Ryan cried in his arms after The Hang. It was Luke who fucked it up, but it was Ry who apologized!.

I don't know. I'm not saying that Luke had to be the hero against Alexis because he would most likely have ended with a bullet in his temples too. However he was never there for Ry when he had to be. Supporting him. Sure, it's easy to hang around laughing about the silliest things, but what matters is where you are when things go dark, and in those moments Ryan Alexis was always alone. That is indeed Luke's fault.

I wouldn't go as far as saying that you've lost a reader, because this is one of the best stories I've ever read and I mean it. You are an amazing writer, and this chapter was great. It's just that I don't know if I'm prepared for another 10 more chapters of emptyness and wolves of any kind before getting to the end. It was hard with Elliott, it was hard with Simon. I don't think I appreciate Luke enough to go through that all over again with him. Not without Ryan.

I do hope that Luke can heal his body and soul. After all he's just 17 and human. He deserves to forgive himself and to be happy, and if he's smart enough he'll realise that there's no one who can understand him more than Elliott. Elliott would be there for him.

Thanks for the review. I suspect that many readers assumed that this was just a last minute plot twist, decided on a whim. However, you are quite right when you quote the main story intro, that Ryan’s death has been planned from the beginning. What I didn’t quite expect back then, was how deep and rich a character he would become, and how badly we would hurt when we lost him. Like I said in the story thread, I’ve had time over several years - knowing this was coming - to grieve for him. I hope you’ll stay with the story so that I can help you do that, too. The end is coming, and I want it to be something good.

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 01:40 AM, nighthawke said:

Again up to your high standard of writing, i think the last thing Luke needs now is Elliot all over him so by telling him to wait i think was the right thing to do. He needs time to reflect on events and of his best friends death. I also think Simon needs to tell Luke what went on between him and Toby.

Hi there. I’m still not sure about Elliott. You could be right and it’s best if he keeps his distance, but then again, if Luke shuts himself away, he’s going to spiral. Maybe he needs friends more than he knows.

 

Thanks for the review.

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 02:36 AM, Beach said:

As I suspected... You already killed off Miquel in your previous story, and now you had to solve the problem of both El and Ry in love with Luke. Since Elliott had already gone through such terrible suffering (in your mind), the easiest solution was to kill off Ryan leaving the way clear for Elliott and Luke. Now the way is also clear to eventually bring the story to a close.

Yet, in so many ways Ryan was the most interesting character in AETC - the strength, the loyalty, the ability to overcome the adversities in his life and still remain whole. Contrasted with Luke who showed little of such sterling character straits - who ran from every threat to his being, who was so busy protecting himself that he failed to consider the emotional and physical suffering of both his brother and Ryan. They needed his support but he left them to deal with it on their own.

Riley, I think you are one of the really good authors on GA - you know how to write an interesting story and keep your readers coming back even after 84 chapters - no mean feat in this genre.

Of course, you are the author and you decide how your story is going to progress. But for me, you missed the boat - you killed off the wrong person, if indeed it was necessary to kill off any of the boys to advance your narrative. If you intend to continue this story for many more chapter, it may well have been Ryan who had the most to offer. Luke is the most flawed, Elliott the weakest (even in the earlier story) and, so far, little more than a two dimensional character.

Perhaps in continuing AETC, Luke, aware of his failings, will grow into a much better person and Elliott will grow into a character with depth.

Finally, these are my own personal comments and not intended as intense criticism. If I didn't care so much for your story telling gifts, I wouldn't have bothered to respond to this chapter.

[i wrote my review before reading any of the other reviews. I see that I'm not the only one who reacted negatively to ending Ryan's life. There is another very prolific and excellent GA author who killed off his strongest character in the first chapter of a continuing story that has gone on for hundreds of chapters. I stopped reading after that initial death - probably my lose since that series has won some awards. I did however read another one of his series which I very much like.]

Hi Beach - and thanks for your honest feedback. As you’ve already read both prior to your posting and afterwards, there’s been a lot of it coming in…and a lot a varies opinions!

 

Riley might have appeared strong, and Luke weak, but who knows which person has more to offer. Actually, aren’t all of us flawed? Yet we’re all still worth something and one isn’t more important than another. Luke is who he is, but what’s important is the choices he now makes and how he choses to live life. That’s the same for Simon…even for Toby. Maybe even for the parents?

 

I suspect, like you say, everyone is going to see this in slightly different ways, but I really appreciate your taking the time and effort to write and spill your thoughts, and for still getting behind the story…and the author!!

 

Thank you!

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 04:54 AM, dughlas said:

Hmm, not what I was hoping for but I think I understand your reasons. I liked Ryan. He won an award as a reader favorite. So yeah I'm saddened that you chose to have him die. Will I abandoned the story ... no. I thought I would do that back when "the hang" was originally posted. You might remember a rather angry post at that time. But I chose to trust you as the author to make it work. I intend the same now but I think you've set yourself a task. Many view Luke as the weaker of the two characters. It easy to judge when we have the benefit of hard evidence that isn't available to the characters who only hints. Ryan worked hard to hide how bad things truly were at home particularly from Luke. Luke himself is judging himself harshly. Ry wanted him to run, to get away, to be safe. What a terrible thing it would be had Luke also vainly fought against Alexis only to die as well. I think we judge Luke's behavior too severely. Look to the recent terrorist attacks, that in essence is what this was on a much more intimate scale, most people fled in panic. Yes, he should have been more supportive when Ry was hung but we need to keep in mind the majority of the guys saw it as sport. Ry stepped in to protect Luke because he was still wearing the klamp there was the potential for serious injury and/or embarassment if Luke had been hung. I don't think even Ry truly understood the humiliation until it happened to him. It wasn't until after Ry, a hero of sorts, that most of the students seemed to understand the ramifications to their "harmless" fun. He, and we, berates himself for not being there for Simon and yet Si put his whole self into keeping what happened between himself and Toby a secret. We fretted because we thought their parents let Si go longer than they should have. Why would we think Luke, a 17 year-old boy might have done more? He tried talking to Si. He can't be blamed that when Si reached the point of almost confiding that something interferred. Had Luke known he would have remained and supported his brother. We know that.

In ISH Elliot was the less sure character. Miguel was the more dominant. But then Miguel was in his environment and Elliot was a more reserved person. As the story progressed Elliot modelled himself more in Miguel's manner. While we haven't seen as much of him yet he seems to have continued in that. It will be interesting to see the person Luke becomes without Ryan's presence. Will he also adopt more of Ry's strengths?

Hi Dughlas. Thanks, as always, for the support - both here and on the story thread. A steadying hand really helps!

 

It’s interesting to see you Luke is judged - not just by readers, but by himself as well. I tend to agree with you that it’s too easy to look at these things in a black and white way. The story is set in a relatively modern well-to-do America, the inference being that these guys have easy lives and no problems. Through Ryan, we see the fallacy of that. Through Luke, too, but in a different way. For me, ET has a cultural thread running through it. Luke and his family are from the UK. He was upended and forced to leave his home to go…and stay…in another country. Now while I don’t think that the trauma of that is anywhere near to that being experienced right now by thousands of refugees around the world, it has its impact. Luke has always struggled to feel he fits where he is. That sense was what underpinned the whole need to become circumcised in the first place! This ‘not fitting’ leads him to float in life, sitting on the fence and waiting to see what others do.

 

Actually, Elliott was the same. ‘the boy with plenty of stamps in his passport, but no friends.’ He found his footing after Miguel - I just hope Luke can, too.

 

Thanks for the review.

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 05:24 AM, Timothy M. said:

:,( I feel such sadness for all of them. Ryan, Luke, Elliot - and for Luke's family. I know why people have a hard time accepting Ryan's death and may not forgive you for it, but storywise it makes sense. Alexis didn't hesitate to shoot the cops because he had already stepped over the line and committed murder. But guess what: I think Ryan would prefer this outcome to one where Luke didn't survive. Still devasting when we were all hoping for a better outcome :(

Many of us like Ryan better than Luke (and some of us like Simon better too), and I'm not the least bit surprised about Luke's reaction and his feelings of guilt. Unlike Simon, who was a victim, Luke has indeed been a coward and not a good friend to Ryan. However, some of the blame resides with his parents who in spite of being caring and loving have failed to instill trust and belief in their sons enough for them to come out to their family. In a wider sense the blame rest squarely on bigots like Ryan's father and the principal and a society where teens cannot be open about their preferences without facing harassment and hate. :pissed:

The worst part is Luke pushing Elliot away and he will probably go into depression. I wonder whether his parents will have learned from Simon's struggles and get him a therapist. At least in Luke's case it's pretty obvious he has had a traumatic experience, so perhaps they'll be sensible. Else Simon hopefully kicks their butts. And I hope Luke's guilt over his brother will mean he cannot shut Simon out. :unsure:

Now of course there are still lots of unanswered questions: What did the papers write? When will the police interview Luke and will his parents be there? Will he tell the truth about being gay or will he lie and say Ryan came out and Alexis mistakenly accused his best friend due to this? Will he tell his parents and / or Simon the same tale? What about Ryan's grandparents? Of course further ahead I wonder what will happen when he goes back to school? And will he realize Elliot is the one person who is able to understand him and the loss he has suffered?

I think its a good thing we can never know the future! If we could time travel, I think we’d spend our lives going back and forth changing things, and then having to go back again to change something else because the outcome never gives us what we want! I wonder what Geoff would have thought if, when he accepted the job at the USA bank when they were living in the UK, that that simple choice would lead to so much carnage?

 

The point is, it’s often hard to pin blame when the things that happen in life are often a result of choices - over which you have no control - that are made, sometimes years before. We do our best with what we’ve got, but nobody can prepare for the Ethan Alexis’s of life.

 

And now it is what it is, and Luke - and the rest - have to deal with what’s in front of them. As you say, still plenty of questions that are unanswered.

 

Thanks again for contributing to the thread in forum, Timothy. That was really helpful and much appreciated.

 

Riley

  • Like 2
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 05:39 AM, Rockon429 said:

I loved Ryan but he was never the driving character in my mind. Luke, while flawed, was always the center. Sure, there were chapters that focused on Ryan and an arc that showed off Toby and Simon; but the story always came back to Luke. Now, some claim that Elliot is not a deep character and doesn't hold the story together. I disagree. In Safe Hands provides Elliot with necessary depth and the lack of detail in English Teen is merely a byproduct of the length of time Elliot has existed in Luke's world. The loss of Ryan won't ruin this story, in fact his death will provide Luke with a new demon to wrestle with. To everyone who believes Ryan's death is the end of this I challenge you to accept the fact that a story can't always save your character, that people die. If Ryan hadn't died I would have feared more for English Teen than if not, because a happy ending to these hard chapters would have most definitely meant the end of any meaningful story.

 

I know that was long and rambly. That's just how I feel after this chapter.

 

Thanks Riley.

I think it’s always easier to place the ‘hero’ as the main character, whereas Luke was never written that way, though, you’re right, he is the main character and connects everything as it flows around him. He’s not the ‘bad guy’ either. He’s just flawed in ways that most of us can identify with. I’m glad now that I took Elliott out of ET and wrote about him first in ISH. Originally, his backstory was part of ET, but a coupe of chapters was never going to be enough, so I wrote his own story first and took it form there.

 

However, like I said in resource to another review, Ryan was somebody we grew to really care for. Even thought its only a story, it hurts to lose him. It will hurt Luke too - he hasn’t yet had a chance to grieve and neither have we.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 06:00 AM, ColumbusGuy said:

This isn't unexpected, Riley since I speculated about it in my last review. I'd have liked to see Ryan survive, but with the time that had elapsed and the sound of two shots, I was fairly sure he was gone. Of the two main guys, he was my favorite over Luke, but in the end he showed what a man he truly was by urging his friend to save himself. I hope he will be an example to Luke in the end, rather than a symbol of his own failure to resist when there wasn't really anything he could do to prevent the rampage.

I don't agree with those who say they will abandon the story now that Ryan is gone--this IS Luke's story of growth and hopeful acceptance of himself, and I think Ryan will have a great influence on that in the end. Luke needs to see Ryan as a positive influence and someone who saw something in Luke that was worth saving. The parallel with Miguel is obvious, so I hope Luke can work through his issues as Elliot did when he lost Miguel.

Tim and Dughlas have it right, so I can't really add to their comments. I only hope that Luke's parents come to grips with their sons' needs at last, rather than remaining oblivious.

Very heart-breaking, Riley, but I'm in for the long haul...I'll miss Ryan a lot though.

I think we all miss Ryan, and wonder what future Luke will have.

 

What we were yesterday isn’t going to be what we are today or what we might become tomorrow. How that changes can depend on who you have around you, so yes, its going one really important how Luke lets other people into his world.

 

Thanks for the encouraging review!

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 10:35 AM, peethree said:

Wow. I'm so sad that Ryan didn't make it. He was my favorite i think of the boys, but I'm not sure where you would have taken the characters with Elliott in the picture. At least he died admitting who he was to Luke and his family and really trying to save Luke and his mom. Luke has a lot to overcome. I think he will need Elliott and Simon's help. I love reading the reviews, but haven't on this chapter because I know some will try to tell you how your story should go. I'll just say it's yours to tell. Looking forward to the next chapter. I'm ready with kleenex jn hand.

With his own dysfunctional family, Ryan saw Luke as a brother. Being the person he was, its not surprising he defended him so extravagantly.

 

Can Luke live up to that?

 

Thanks for keeping reading Peethree.

 

Riley

  • Wow 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 11:25 AM, cgoldsmith said:

Riley, as I said about Chapter 78, Ryan is the Christ-figure of the story, but I had hoped it wouldn't include his death. One of his last acts is to help save Luke. He had incredible strength of character. Since he was almost raising himself, where did his moral compass come from? He was very young to be as centered as he was. I was really curious to see his further development. Now it cannot be. I will miss him a lot. Maybe that was your intention all along....

I’m fairly sure that moral compass and that strength of character came from his grandparents - Brigadier and Mrs Buford.

 

I think we’re all missing him.

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 11:25 AM, Medraut said:

I've always been rather scared to review, biding my time. Y'know, it takes a great amount of courage to kill one of your characters. Yes, I'm sad and I was holding my breath, hoping Ryan'd live. But, I think, I knew that this chapter'd have terrible news. I'm hoping that Ryan's mum lived and she'll be able to cling to Luke and the two'll get through it.

Hello Medraut. Firstly, thank you for putting down a review. It was great to hear from you.

 

As you say, it wasn’t the news readers were hoping for, and a bit of a shock to come to terms with the idea that Ryan is no longer physically part of the story. It’s going to be hard for Luke to move on.

 

Maybe the next chapter will bring more news…and hope.

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On 07/31/2016 06:29 PM, Bleu said:

There are quite a number of reviews already, and the grieving process has understandably started among your readers. I am sad about Ryan's murder because he was a lovable character with a lot to look forward to in life. Luke will miss him and probably feel guilty at everything he could have done and said earlier... plus the fact that he punched him in the face in the school parking lot and then rejected him in favour of Elliott a little later.

I was surprised by Ryan's death — not because it couldn't happen: clearly you know where you are taking this story and I trust you to make the rest of the story come together — but because some clues pointed to him surviving: Luke never witnessed him being murdered, and the previous chapter ended on a light note from Todd. It does feel a little cruel for the reader. You could have brought up Ryan's death in the "kitchen scene" 3 chapters ago and the outcome would have been the same for Luke. I am just wondering why you chose to hide Ryan's death to the reader, building our hopes up to send them crashing down later.

As for Luke and Elliott, I doubt that Elliott will let this be the end. Luke needs him now more than ever, and he also needs to be out to his parents. I don't know whether he will have a choice in this, but in any case he needs to own up to his feelings. Simon may well play a decisive supporting role in it.

Yes, I accept that I deliberately misdirected in regards to Ryan’s death. Evan now, nobody knows exactly how that happened. Did it raise your hopes? Yes. Was it meant to do that? Ummmm… Yes. Is it over yet? No.

 

Hopefully the next chapter will peel back the curtains a little bit more. As I said in the forum story thread, Elliott gets where Luke is right now. he understands loss and guilt, and the last things he’ll do is try to offer answers.

 

Thanks for the review, Bleu

Riley

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
On 08/01/2016 03:54 AM, Lisa said:

I read this last night on my phone right before bed. Big mistake. I cried myself to sleep. I'm still crying.

 

Ryan was a lovable character. He pretty much got his mother to the point of leaving that psycho she married, and then this happened. No one knew the pain Ryan lived with every day. No one knew his sperm donor (he will never have the right to be called a father) physically and verbally abused him and his mother. His grandparents didn't know, right? I can't see how his grandparents would stand for that if they knew.

 

Luke is going to be in a very bad place for a long time to come. He'll feel guilty for not saving Ryan. He'll feel guilty for surviving when his best friend didn't. One of your readers pointed this out and I totally agree; Luke should see the therapist Simon was going to see. Oh, and yes, that's another thing Luke is going to feel guilty about: not being there for Simon.

 

My heart goes out to Luke and Ryan's grandparents. Elliot too. Luke's right; there's no way he can be in any kind of relationship now. He's too fucked up. I hope Elliot will still be there when Luke is ready. Personally, I think Luke should think of Elliot as a part of his support system. He's going to need him as a friend at least.

 

When all the shit has settled, Luke should come out to his parents. Actually, he should do it while he's still in the hospital. Of course it shouldn't matter to them at all, but...in case they're close-minded idiots, I think they won't care -- as long as Luke is going to be ok physically, they won't care. Just my opinion.

 

Ok, well, I need to go out and buy more Kleenex. I'll send you the bill, Riley. :,(

Oh Lisa… Crying’s good. I think the world would be a better place if we cried more easily at the things that are wrong in it!

 

No, I don’t think the grandparents knew the full awfulness of how the family had to live. I expect Alexis put on a show whenever they were around just to make sure the money didn’t dry up.

 

Yep, Luke is in a mess, and it’s not going to come good ‘just like that’. In regards to coming out…will Luke finally get off that fence?

 

Thanks Lisa,

Riley

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
On 08/01/2016 01:46 PM, Emi GS said:

I am sorry, I don't have any words right now other than 'Bye'.

 

~Emi GS.

Hey Emi - we’ve talked separately to this both in the forum and through IM, so I know you’re finding your way through this. I hope you’ll keep reading. As I said elsewhere, I’ve been able to grieve for Ryan for some time as I’ve know this was coming. I just hope you’ll keep with the story so you’ll give me the chance to help you to properly grieve for him, too. Only then will it make sense.

 

Riley

  • Like 1
Link to comment

I worried after reading reviews that you’ve killed off major characters before but I was hoping Ryan was alive plus I didn’t think Todd would have been so upbeat if Ryan were dead so that gave me hope. In the end I had already come to the conclusion based on the chapter when Ryan confessed his feelings that Luke wouldn’t end with him as Elliot seemed to be the one for Luke. Elliot though In this chapter came off a little self centered as Ryan aka Luke’s best friend is dead yet all he could think about was his jealousy over the idea Luke may have had sex with him  and he’s upset that Luke needs time after not only losing his best friend but almost dying. I mean come on the guy just woke up after being unconscious for days and it’s all about you? That is not the best start to a relationship.

  • Love 1
Link to comment

I am so pissed! I read anymore of this story. I know characters get killed off, but I was so invested in Ryan & Luke. Again I'm sorry. I did enjoy this story till now.

  • Love 1
Link to comment

No.  I can’t continue reading this story.  We see enough sadness in everyday life, I don’t want have to read about it. It was such a good story too  :(

  • Love 1
Link to comment
On 7/30/2016 at 9:39 AM, ephoebusbosch said:

I was half prepared for this. Half. Well...it's not like you didn't warn us well in advance <<in this extraordinary tale of life, love and loss>> Deep down I knew that you planned to kill him from the very beginning, and when those two shots echoed through the house while Luke was hiding, that pretty much settled it for me.
Luke blames himself. I know it's not his fault at all, Alexis was a crazy bastard and something like this was bound to happen sooner than later, but Luke's right in one thing: he's not like Elliott. He did leave Ryan "hanging" more than once. He's always been happy just standing by to see what happens. Hell, if I suspected that a friend of mine was going through something similar to Ryan, I'd be there. I'd hug him. I'd cheer him up. I'd try to help. I feel like Luke was never there to Ryan before apart from when Ryan cried in his arms after The Hang. It was Luke who fucked it up, but it was Ry who apologized!.
I don't know. I'm not saying that Luke had to be the hero against Alexis because he would most likely have ended with a bullet in his temples too. However he was never there for Ry when he had to be. Supporting him. Sure, it's easy to hang around laughing about the silliest things, but what matters is where you are when things go dark, and in those moments Ryan Alexis was always alone. That is indeed Luke's fault.
I wouldn't go as far as saying that you've lost a reader, because this is one of the best stories I've ever read and I mean it. You are an amazing writer, and this chapter was great. It's just that I don't know if I'm prepared for another 10 more chapters of emptyness and wolves of any kind before getting to the end. It was hard with Elliott, it was hard with Simon. I don't think I appreciate Luke enough to go through that all over again with him. Not without Ryan.
I do hope that Luke can heal his body and soul. After all he's just 17 and human. He deserves to forgive himself and to be happy, and if he's smart enough he'll realise that there's no one who can understand him more than Elliott. Elliott would be there for him.

 

On 7/30/2016 at 10:36 AM, Beach said:

As I suspected... You already killed off Miquel in your previous story, and now you had to solve the problem of both El and Ry in love with Luke. Since Elliott had already gone through such terrible suffering (in your mind), the easiest solution was to kill off Ryan leaving the way clear for Elliott and Luke. Now the way is also clear to eventually bring the story to a close.
Yet, in so many ways Ryan was the most interesting character in AETC - the strength, the loyalty, the ability to overcome the adversities in his life and still remain whole. Contrasted with Luke who showed little of such sterling character straits - who ran from every threat to his being, who was so busy protecting himself that he failed to consider the emotional and physical suffering of both his brother and Ryan. They needed his support but he left them to deal with it on their own.
Riley, I think you are one of the really good authors on GA - you know how to write an interesting story and keep your readers coming back even after 84 chapters - no mean feat in this genre.
Of course, you are the author and you decide how your story is going to progress. But for me, you missed the boat - you killed off the wrong person, if indeed it was necessary to kill off any of the boys to advance your narrative. If you intend to continue this story for many more chapter, it may well have been Ryan who had the most to offer. Luke is the most flawed, Elliott the weakest (even in the earlier story) and, so far, little more than a two dimensional character.
Perhaps in continuing AETC, Luke, aware of his failings, will grow into a much better person and Elliott will grow into a character with depth.
Finally, these are my own personal comments and not intended as intense criticism. If I didn't care so much for your story telling gifts, I wouldn't have bothered to respond to this chapter.
[i wrote my review before reading any of the other reviews. I see that I'm not the only one who reacted negatively to ending Ryan's life. There is

On 7/30/2016 at 12:54 PM, dughlas said:

Hmm, not what I was hoping for but I think I understand your reasons. I liked Ryan. He won an award as a reader favorite. So yeah I'm saddened that you chose to have him die. Will I abandoned the story ... no. I thought I would do that back when "the hang" was originally posted. You might remember a rather angry post at that time. But I chose to trust you as the author to make it work. I intend the same now but I think you've set yourself a task. Many view Luke as the weaker of the two characters. It easy to judge when we have the benefit of hard evidence that isn't available to the characters who only hints. Ryan worked hard to hide how bad things truly were at home particularly from Luke. Luke himself is judging himself harshly. Ry wanted him to run, to get away, to be safe. What a terrible thing it would be had Luke also vainly fought against Alexis only to die as well. I think we judge Luke's behavior too severely. Look to the recent terrorist attacks, that in essence is what this was on a much more intimate scale, most people fled in panic. Yes, he should have been more supportive when Ry was hung but we need to keep in mind the majority of the guys saw it as sport. Ry stepped in to protect Luke because he was still wearing the klamp there was the potential for serious injury and/or embarassment if Luke had been hung. I don't think even Ry truly understood the humiliation until it happened to him. It wasn't until after Ry, a hero of sorts, that most of the students seemed to understand the ramifications to their "harmless" fun. He, and we, berates himself for not being there for Simon and yet Si put his whole self into keeping what happened between himself and Toby a secret. We fretted because we thought their parents let Si go longer than they should have. Why would we think Luke, a 17 year-old boy might have done more? He tried talking to Si. He can't be blamed that when Si reached the point of almost confiding that something interferred. Had Luke known he would have remained and supported his brother. We know that.
In ISH Elliot was the less sure character. Miguel was the more dominant. But then Miguel was in his environment and Elliot was a more reserved person. As the story progressed Elliot modelled himself more in Miguel's manner. While we haven't seen as much of him yet he seems to have continued in that. It will be interesting to see the person Luke becomes without Ryan's presence. Will he also adopt more of Ry's strengths?

 

On 7/30/2016 at 1:24 PM, Timothy M. said:

:,( I feel such sadness for all of them. Ryan, Luke, Elliot - and for Luke's family. I know why people have a hard time accepting Ryan's death and may not forgive you for it, but storywise it makes sense. Alexis didn't hesitate to shoot the cops because he had already stepped over the line and committed murder. But guess what: I think Ryan would prefer this outcome to one where Luke didn't survive. Still devasting when we were all hoping for a better outcome :(
Many of us like Ryan better than Luke (and some of us like Simon better too), and I'm not the least bit surprised about Luke's reaction and his feelings of guilt. Unlike Simon, who was a victim, Luke has indeed been a coward and not a good friend to Ryan. However, some of the blame resides with his parents who in spite of being caring and loving have failed to instill trust and belief in their sons enough for them to come out to their family. In a wider sense the blame rest squarely on bigots like Ryan's father and the principal and a society where teens cannot be open about their preferences without facing harassment and hate. :pissed:
The worst part is Luke pushing Elliot away and he will probably go into depression. I wonder whether his parents will have learned from Simon's struggles and get him a therapist. At least in Luke's case it's pretty obvious he has had a traumatic experience, so perhaps they'll be sensible. Else Simon hopefully kicks their butts. And I hope Luke's guilt over his brother will mean he cannot shut Simon out. :unsure:
Now of course there are still lots of unanswered questions: What did the papers write? When will the police interview Luke and will his parents be there? Will he tell the truth about being gay or will he lie and say Ryan came out and Alexis mistakenly accused his best friend due to this? Will he tell his parents and / or Simon the same tale? What about Ryan's grandparents? Of course further ahead I wonder what will happen when he goes back to school? And will he realize Elliot is the one person who is able to understand him and the loss he has suffered?

another very prolific and excellent GA author who killed off his strongest character in the first chapter of a continuing story that has gone on for hundreds of chapters. I stopped reading after that initial death - probably my lose since that series has won some awards. I did however read another one of his series which I very much like.]

 

On 7/30/2016 at 2:00 PM, ColumbusGuy said:

This isn't unexpected, Riley since I speculated about it in my last review. I'd have liked to see Ryan survive, but with the time that had elapsed and the sound of two shots, I was fairly sure he was gone. Of the two main guys, he was my favorite over Luke, but in the end he showed what a man he truly was by urging his friend to save himself. I hope he will be an example to Luke in the end, rather than a symbol of his own failure to resist when there wasn't really anything he could do to prevent the rampage.
I don't agree with those who say they will abandon the story now that Ryan is gone--this IS Luke's story of growth and hopeful acceptance of himself, and I think Ryan will have a great influence on that in the end. Luke needs to see Ryan as a positive influence and someone who saw something in Luke that was worth saving. The parallel with Miguel is obvious, so I hope Luke can work through his issues as Elliot did when he lost Miguel.
Tim and Dughlas have it right, so I can't really add to their comments. I only hope that Luke's parents come to grips with their sons' needs at last, rather than remaining oblivious.
Very heart-breaking, Riley, but I'm in for the long haul...I'll miss Ryan a lot though.

 

On 7/31/2016 at 11:54 AM, Lisa said:

I read this last night on my phone right before bed. Big mistake. I cried myself to sleep. I'm still crying.

 

Ryan was a lovable character. He pretty much got his mother to the point of leaving that psycho she married, and then this happened. No one knew the pain Ryan lived with every day. No one knew his sperm donor (he will never have the right to be called a father) physically and verbally abused him and his mother. His grandparents didn't know, right? I can't see how his grandparents would stand for that if they knew.

 

Luke is going to be in a very bad place for a long time to come. He'll feel guilty for not saving Ryan. He'll feel guilty for surviving when his best friend didn't. One of your readers pointed this out and I totally agree; Luke should see the therapist Simon was going to see. Oh, and yes, that's another thing Luke is going to feel guilty about: not being there for Simon.

 

My heart goes out to Luke and Ryan's grandparents. Elliot too. Luke's right; there's no way he can be in any kind of relationship now. He's too fucked up. I hope Elliot will still be there when Luke is ready. Personally, I think Luke should think of Elliot as a part of his support system. He's going to need him as a friend at least.

 

When all the shit has settled, Luke should come out to his parents. Actually, he should do it while he's still in the hospital. Of course it shouldn't matter to them at all, but...in case they're close-minded idiots, I think they won't care -- as long as Luke is going to be ok physically, they won't care. Just my opinion.

 

Ok, well, I need to go out and buy more Kleenex. I'll send you the bill, Riley. :,(

 

Riley, with so many others, I am INCREDIBLY ANGRY about your decision to kill Ryan off rather than allow him to escape with his grandparents, either with or without some life-altering injuries. It's just another example of "Bury Your Gays," and I expect better from a gay author. I'll finish the story, but much of my emotional investment is cashed out at this point.

Yes, Luke has much to answer for: abandoning Ryan in so many ways -- especially after the Hang -- not paying attention to Simon, and especially abandoning himself. I, too, hope he can get out of the bleachers and onto the field. Shock. Denial. Anger. Bargaining. Depression. They're all in Luke's future as he navigates his complicated grief and trauma. Therapy and friends are the only way to work this all out, and it will be HARD work. I wish him the best.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

View Guidelines

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Newsletter

    Sign Up and get an occasional Newsletter.  Fill out your profile with favorite genres and say yes to genre news to get the monthly update for your favorite genres.

    Sign Up
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Our Privacy Policy can be found here: Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..