Jump to content
  • entries
    41
  • comments
    68
  • views
    2,718

Twinkie Defense and White Night Riot


Ashi

379 views

blog-0791134001347349905.jpg(For best experience, please watch each video clip in order it is inserted before moving onto the segment that follows it)

 

It was September 4, 2012 when I saw him: George Moscone, or the likeness of him, in San Francisco Museum of Art (SFMOMA). The livid color attracted me, and his smile, as if he was alive and happy. I took a look of the inscription that puts him on the pedestal:

 

Harvey Milk Too

Twinkies

Danny Boy!

Diane Feinstein Becomes Mayor

 

Without thinking much, I took a black and white photo of him, along with a painting of him with my camera and brought the film home (yes, a film camera).

 

Days later, after I received the scanned photos on a CD, I reviewed that photo of him more closely. Who was that man, and who made the sculpture of him. Sure, I have some rudimentary knowledge that he was the mayor of San Francisco, and he was assassinated along with Harvey Milk, both key figures in gay history, or at least in California, but I would like to know more about the inspiration of the art.

 

As an artist myself, I believe the purpose of art is to promote thinking. Certainly the inscription on the pedestal is a good starting point of that thought process. I Googled "Portrait of Moscone Robert Arneson."

 

Now,
30 years after
the piece riled a San Francisco still raw from the 1978
killings of Moscone and Supervisor Harvey Milk
,
"Portrait of George" is
coming home to the city that
commissioned then
rejected it
.

 

* * *

 

Then-Mayor
Dianne Feinstein
directed the Arts Commission, which had commissioned the piece and paid Arneson half of the $37,000 fee, to reject it unless he agreed to change the pedestal. In 2000, now-Sen. Feinstein told Chronicle staff writer Mike Weiss that because of the pain and polarization in the city after the Jonestown massacre, the assassinations and the White Night riots, "I
did not feel it was appropriate public art
at the time. And I felt and feel very strongly about Gina (Moscone) and the family and what they had gone through."

 

 

Arneson
, who was known for his irreverence and comic bite and obviously
wasn't going to cast a heroic bronze
, refused to alter the piece and
returned the fee
.
[
]

 

 

 

 

It was a different time. A time in history when public figures murdered in cold blood was considered a shocking, unthinkable event. It was the year I was born, which makes it even more unreal, as I don't think it's that far back in time.

 

The murder of the San Francisco mayor reminds me of the movie Milk, which is focused on Harvey Milk who was murdered along with him by Dan White.

 

 

[media]

 

People left comments on the video reflecting anger over the questionable judiciary system, with Dan White was only convicted and sentenced for five years in prison for the murder of two men. The possibility of a movie made about Dan White surfaced, as it is dramatic in its own right, through the eyes of a murderer. Why he killed Moscone and Harvey Milk? How is that possible to carry out in broad light in city hall? Was he suicidal in prison as his defense lawyer and prison supervisors would make the public believe? Was the crime conducted out of political reason, or as speculated, because he was a homophobe? What was the cause and reason for his eventual suicide, two years after he was out of prison? Or was that a result of street justice? Was it really a murder out of diminished capacity (temporary insanity plead, with too much sugary consumption? Twinkie Defense) or is it premeditated as reported by homicide detective Frank Falzon? So many questions, and so many possibilities.

 

No matter what the answers are, the people are angry.

 

[media]

 

It was an interesting mental journey back in time. A piece of gay history. And it was all because of a bust with graffiti-like inscription on its pedestal.

0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Our Privacy Policy can be found here: Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..