@Cia A long time ago, prompted by Myr and Mann talking about how thorough your editing was, I asked you to edit for me. You turned me down. Your loss, toots. There went your chance to rip me a new one.
@Myr I agree readers should react to a story whichever way they feel like. Some of us thrive on critical reactions because we want to improve. Other authors may be interested in writing and posting not worrying about what anyone thinks. Both approaches are valid.
My chapters get a good number of reactions and comments, but my stories will never be among the most recommended or reviewed. No idea why. I have mentioned it a couple of times, but I'm past begging for reactions every chapter. A newer author might not be as secure in their writing and crave positive reinforcement, so the constant reminders might be just what they need.
I use every tool available to provide feedback. And yes, in a few instances when my criticism was extremely harsh, I've used PMs. But an author trying to restrict any sort of reaction is wrong. Evaluating artistic endeavors will always be subjective (think of the East German gymnastics judge giving a Westerner a lower score) and will not always be favorable. Aside from the 'this story and you suck' comments, we can learn from most reactions to our work. Although I'm still wondering why someone ranked a story of mine without a sex scene in it as 'smoldering.'
The author who demands all reviews include 5-star ratings should consider offering a better product. Even then, it's up to the reader. More stars won't mean I read anything. I rely on tags, descriptions, recommendations, reviews, reactions, and comments when deciding what to read. GA offers multiple ways for readers to react so why limit myself?
To readers: Do as you please. Say what you mean and mean what you say.
To authors: Stop whining. Use what you get and learn from it.
PS Inflation in reactions reminds me of grade inflation in schools or participation trophies. Positive reinforcement is fine, but sometimes we have to call trash what it is.