"I believe that a scientist looking at nonscientific problems is just as dumb as the next guy."
Richard Feynman
regarding the example, the point was non-rhetorical, the example was seething with received notions.
I have not stated my personal theology because as far as my arguments are concerend, it is irrelevant. I am among the "against abortion, then don't have one" and "pro child & pro choice" crowd, in that my moral beliefs apply to me and not others. While I refuse to get semantical, there are huge differences between personal morals, societal mores and behavioral ethics.
I don't view fantasies as having good/bad value judgements because a true fantasy exists outside of our relationships with others (except your Deity(ies) if you so believe). Good/bad only has meaning in relation to others (things or people). I don't believe that thoughts or feelings are ever good/bad, actions are good or bad based on the relationship. The relationship key is critical because it requires the connection of the beliefs of two (or more) people.
Now, the act of reading a story or viewing still or moving images is a behavior, and the value of that behavior is based on relationships. For a single guy at home one evening to get off on Vampire Jared as opposed to an encounter between Owen and Aiden, or an innocent marshmallow lick between Jude and Quinn isn't a situation of good/bad. If he is avoiding his friends or a partner in order to spend his time reading the material, or if he has a partner who has a strong belief about reading/viewing certain materials, then values have a place, but the value is in the relationship, not the material.
Also, if you relationship with your Deity is affected by your viewing of such material, then you may place your own personal moral jusdgement on the use of such material for yourself. To a prior ascribe those same values/morals to others for their private (non-relationship) behaviors is no differnet than requireing them to hold you theological views.
So, the label of porn/erotica as a bad/good label only applies when the behavior is brought outside of the individual and is placed within a relationship.
Snow Dog the Domaholic Danderthal