Jump to content
  • entries
    48
  • comments
    589
  • views
    4,939

Abomination

Wayne Gray

Entry posted by Wayne Gray

554 views

 Share

I manage medical labs. Part of that management is I decide which tests ordered by our providers are integrated into our EMR (electronic medical record). Some will never be "mapped," as it's called, because they're esoteric, or just too rarely ordered; it takes effort and time to do this mapping, so we pick and choose which get added.

Well at the request of a number of providers who particularly like this odd genetic-based test for cancer screening, I began the process of mapping this new item.

Part of that mapping process includes digging up something called CPT codes assigned to the testing. So I contact the company. I ask for the codes, as they're not available on their website (an oddity I could overlook). This lady tells me, "Oh the CPT codes change based on payor. You know, the insurance."

I sat there a moment, then finally found my voice. "So ... what you're telling me is based on how good someone's insurance is, your organization is picking and choosing which procedures to run, completely apart from the legal orders submitted by the provider?"

Silence for a good twenty seconds. "Uh," *whispering to someone* "I think I need to give you to my supervisor."

"That sounds great."

"Please hold."

"Sure."

I'm put on hold. Five minutes later I get a guy. "Hi, I hear you have questions about our test?"

"I sure do." I repeat my question, and add, "Feel free to tell me I'm wrong. Because unlicensed individuals making medical judgments based on financial situations is antithetical to everything my organization stands for. So I'd love to be able to tell my medical directors that isn't happening."

Silence. Finally, a cleared throat. "I feel as if there's no good way to answer your question at the moment. I'll have to do some research and get back to you. May I have your phone number?"

"Sure."

I hung up after I gave him my number.

Here we are. This ... right here, is why for profit healthcare is an abomination.

Edit: 18 June 2020 - Still no call. I've dropped this into the lap of our compliance officer. He's talking about turning them over to CMS (the folks governing MediCal - California's version of Medicaid) for fraud. That could end them entirely if CMS decides to go after them. Good riddance.

  • Like 1
  • Wow 2
  • Sad 1
  • Angry 8
 Share

15 Comments

Recommended Comments

  • Popular Comment
Mikiesboy

Mikiesboy 143,946

Posted (edited)

  • Popular Comment

OMG ... omg ... that is ... i can't even ... what will work here?  Horrific.. an abomination are the perfect words. 

 

Edited by Mikiesboy
  • Like 8
  • Popular Comment
Wayne Gray

Wayne Gray 41,789

Posted

  • Popular Comment
9 minutes ago, Mikiesboy said:

OMG ... omg ... that is ... i can't even ... what will work here?  Horrific.. an abomination are the perfect words. 

I keep hoping they're wrong. Maybe I got the wrong information, and they're just mistaken. If it's not the wrong information, then they're breaking all sorts of laws. There's a lot of financial incentive to do so, and getting caught will mean a fine - one that is easily offset by the amount they stand to earn from this practice.

  • Like 5
  • Angry 1
  • Popular Comment
Mikiesboy

Mikiesboy 143,946

Posted

  • Popular Comment
1 minute ago, Wayne Gray said:

I keep hoping they're wrong. Maybe I got the wrong information, and they're just mistaken. If it's not the wrong information, then they're breaking all sorts of laws. There's a lot of financial incentive to do so, and getting caught will mean a fine - one that is easily offset by the amount they stand to earn from this practice.

i've long known people are just fodder for the machine ... we are nothing next to the almighty dollar.   I hope they made a mistake too.

  • Like 6
  • Love 2
  • Popular Comment
Wayne Gray

Wayne Gray 41,789

Posted

  • Popular Comment
4 minutes ago, Mikiesboy said:

i've long known people are just fodder for the machine ... we are nothing next to the almighty dollar.   I hope they made a mistake too.

I'll make them pay for it if they didn't. We will never send another test to them if this is true.

This is my sphere. If I tell my boss this company is committing fraud and using the names of our providers to accomplish it, then they will never see the name of another of our patients.

We'll see if that's necessary.

  • Like 6
  • Love 2
kbois

kbois 120,446

Posted

18 minutes ago, Wayne Gray said:

I'll make them pay for it if they didn't. We will never send another test to them if this is true.

This is my sphere. If I tell my boss this company is committing fraud and using the names of our providers to accomplish it, then they will never see the name of another of our patients.

We'll see if that's necessary.

Wow. 

You are definitely doing the right thing. Insurance companies have no interest in the people they are there to serve. Bottom line will always  be profit. Same can be said for pharmaceutical companies. 

  • Like 5
  • Popular Comment
MichaelS36

MichaelS36 25,662

Posted

  • Popular Comment

Jesus, Wayne. Our system is not perfect, but I've never heard of this .. 

  • Like 6
  • Popular Comment
Wayne Gray

Wayne Gray 41,789

Posted (edited)

  • Popular Comment
32 minutes ago, kbois said:

Wow. 

You are definitely doing the right thing. Insurance companies have no interest in the people they are there to serve. Bottom line will always  be profit. Same can be said for pharmaceutical companies. 

It's all woefully broken.

There was a prompt ... it said:

"Write a story about someone with the ability to heal wounds, but the healing took a horrible toll."

The single response, because there was no other that bested it ...

"The US Healthcare system"

Edited by Wayne Gray
  • Like 4
  • Sad 2
kbois

kbois 120,446

Posted

19 minutes ago, MichaelS36 said:

Jesus, Wayne. Our system is not perfect, but I've never heard of this .. 

It sucks. It's the same system that let's companies offer insurance to their employees which cost the worker over $700 per month for a family plan which has a $6,000 PER PERSON deductible/$12,000 family deductible. Then you are still on the hook for 20% of all costs after the deductible is met. 

Throw in a government that penalizes you for not having insurance and only offers a subsidized plan if your employer dosen't offer you insurance. 

That's just one example. No matter how you do the math, most people are one major medical event away from bankruptcy.

It's more than broken, it's shattered. 

 

  • Like 3
  • Wow 1
  • Sad 1
  • Popular Comment
Brayon

Brayon 40,953

Posted

  • Popular Comment

My last job before disability was working at United Healthcare as a Provider Phone Rep. I talked to medical providers all day about benefits and claims. The part that always got me was when a provider called in and said, "We billed $2000.00 for this procedure, but you only paid us $50.00." The typical response was, "That's the contracted rate you agreed upon when you signed said contract. Shall I give you the number to your contract sales representative to get a copy of your contract and to discuss future contracts?"

Then I cried a little inside, thinking how much people without insurance get charged because people can't read contracts. So they are recouping the loss upon them.

  • Like 7
  • Popular Comment
Wayne Gray

Wayne Gray 41,789

Posted

  • Popular Comment
17 minutes ago, MichaelS36 said:

Jesus, Wayne. Our system is not perfect, but I've never heard of this .. 

Greed is an ugly beast and our system is run by it.

I work right in the guts of it. I know what I'm talking about. We work so hard to deliver care to those who need it most, in such a flawed and damaged system ... and then we have these fuckers who bleed dry anybody they come in contact with.

I'm not good company tonight. Sorry.

  • Like 5
  • Sad 2
Wayne Gray

Wayne Gray 41,789

Posted

3 minutes ago, Brayon said:

My last job before disability was working at United Healthcare as a Provider Phone Rep. I talked to medical providers all day about benefits and claims. The part that always got me was when a provider called in and said, "We billed $2000.00 for this procedure, but you only paid us $50.00." The typical response was, "That's the contracted rate you agreed upon when you signed said contract. Shall I give you the number to your contract sales representative to get a copy of your contract and to discuss future contracts?"

Then I cried a little inside, thinking how much people without insurance get charged because people can't read contracts. So they are recouping the loss upon them.

The companies will always get their money, and it doesn't matter who is in the way.

  • Like 2
  • Sad 3
Brayon

Brayon 40,953

Posted

1 minute ago, Wayne Gray said:

The companies will always get their money, and it doesn't matter who is in the way.

And Hospitals are the fucking worse.

  • Like 3
  • Popular Comment
MichaelS36

MichaelS36 25,662

Posted

  • Popular Comment
54 minutes ago, Wayne Gray said:

Greed is an ugly beast and our system is run by it.

I work right in the guts of it. I know what I'm talking about. We work so hard to deliver care to those who need it most, in such a flawed and damaged system ... and then we have these fuckers who bleed dry anybody they come in contact with.

I'm not good company tonight. Sorry.

You are always good company.  You are a good man Wayne. You care in a world where caring is in short supply.

Our world will die because of money, the need for it.  We see it now, oh we were all so worried about those people in Walmart and grocery stores ...given a couple of bucks an hour more...while store profit soared. But that has got to stop. They aren't quite as essential as we thought.  Billionaires who can't give their staff a decent wage. Ikea and others who refuse to pay taxes in countries where they are. Greed...

We cannot sustain this kind of society. It is profit-centric. ..it needs to change to become community -centric. It is the only way we will survive ourselves.

  • Like 4
  • Love 2
Thorn Wilde

Thorn Wilde 27,004

Posted

Ugh, that's just horrifying... I hate this world sometimes. 

  • Like 3
Wayne Gray

Wayne Gray 41,789

Posted

Thanks for the comments, all of you.

A little update: Still no call. I've dropped this into the lap of our compliance officer. He's talking about turning them over to CMS (the folks governing MediCal - California's version of Medicaid) for fraud. That could end them entirely if CMS decides to go after them. Good riddance.

  • Like 1
  • Love 3

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...