Wow, thanks for that very detailed review. It's great!
Yeah, I realized that thing about proof reading, haha. This was my first stab at a novel and every time I read to edit, I found errors new errors each time. >.< There are even several writing rules there that I break which I didn't know were wrong till someone pointed it out in another story. I tried going back to edit this but it took too much time away from writing new things. Haha.
I also didn't have an editor or beta reader for this one so all errors here are mine. I might get help for the next one.
This story actually incubated in my imagination for several months before I started writing it. I love stories where things "all come together" in the end rather than "this happened, then this, then this." I wanted to give the same thing to my readers.
Regarding the timeline, my biggest challenge was that I had released the story while writing it. When I first started writing A:TSW, there were supposed to be less than 30 chapters (I think 27?). The gaps between parts (such as what you pointed out with Madame Rooste) were supposed to be shorter. But I found out later on that I could not squeeze in the story to fewer chapters unless I had chapters consistently over 10,000 words long or that I took out certain plot points. I couldn't have either of those. It's something I'm working to fix though for the next part.
I'm glad you liked that scene with the gryphon riders. I liked writing that even if it felt a bit awkward writing a sexual scene.
Haha. I'm already needing bodyguards to protect me from my Charlie readers. But yes, that's a theme (perhaps device?) I use in this story which will occur again in the sequel where certain issues left unresolved in A:TSW come to a close.
Regarding spirit freedom, I have not forgotten (nor overlooked) that part. It was just not central to this story but will be highly relevant in the sequels.
Unfortunately, Magister Aenhol will not be the High Mage Lord any time soon. However, I'm sure you've noticed a vacancy.
With my schedule, it will take some time for Book Two to come out. However, I'm working on a Interlude story which involves a character relevant for Book Two but has not been introduced in A:TSW. I'm going full steam ahead on that one after Charlie is done.
Again, thank you for the review and I hope you like Charlie also when you start reading it.