You already have my take on things, before posting, but I want to see you blush.
It would be tough to name a more sympathetic character than Gibby, but you didn't make him saccharine. You made him noble and loyal, trying to pick up a life of shattered dreams. I wanted to take him home with me. Tanner was another story - just another golden god who actually turned out nicer than I'd ever expect - accepting, non-judgmental, and loyal, even to Amanda. Shelby, in the epilogue, made me hurt, because I felt the depth of her pain.
The epilogue added great depth to a story that otherwise would have had a storybook ending, and you handled it very well.
Plot lines have always been a strong point for you, and this story is no different. Your characters have come a long way, though, and I'm glad you pump up the narrative more. It makes the work more enjoyable. The one bit of narrative that I found coolest was the bit of fluff floating through the house at the beginning. It reminded me of the credits for Forrest Gump. It slowed the pace and distracted the reader for just the right amount of time.
When you first sent me the piece, you asked me about explicit sex scenes, and said you didn't feel right about them with this story. That was a great call. It's still intimate, but not TMI. There's an innocence about the whole piece that could have gone somewhere else.
I'm sorry this story came to an end. I'll miss the characters. They've become real to me. But at least I can stop sniffling now.
One of the things I like most about working with you is that you listen to suggestions, but you follow your instincts. No matter whether you take a suggestion or not, the work is unmistakably yours. And, damn! I like it.