Jump to content
  • entries
    431
  • comments
    824
  • views
    199,771

Websites and Internet: Examples of Moral establishment


W_L

559 views

It just hit me like a ton of bricks, the internet itself is a moral standard.

 

Think of it this way, each website has their own code of conduct and terms/use provisions. In essence, it is almost like a a religion setting out their commandments and tenets. People follow the rules in fear of divine retribution through God/Gods or in this case Mod/Mods/Admins of websites and forum.

 

However, what if people start testing the limits of the rules? What if there is no divine retribution or plagues set against you?

 

At first you will only have a few outliers, a few people that are placed in the anti-social category or the "strange" kids table among the population, who are shunned. Then, as time goes by, the rules grow older and the rule adherents start to be more lax. Two decades ago, if asked, whether killing an innocent person in order to stop terrorism was right? Most people would say no as they'd view it as overkill and immoral in the traditional sense. However, as a society we have moved beyond those rules over time, testing the limits until today, when most people agree there are times that the "good of the many must outweigh the good of the few or one".

 

Similarly, I have a theory that websites and forums are also undergoing similar process of evolution and devolution in their rules and limits. As they age, the original members and new adherents grow lax, then they test the system. The phenomenon of internet trolls are a reflection of this testing of weaknesses in the guise of LOLs. As their behavior becomes justified and mundane, others attempt to try more extreme ways of testing until you reach the point where the rules can no longer be used to hold users to a standard.

 

Personally, I don't believe in moral standards, because I believe that in either religious or technological example of moral standards, the divine or administrative power must be in direct control at all times enforcing their rules. Without eternal vigilance by either, moral standards are merely untested assumptions.

 

Here's an interesting idea to consider about the nature of perfection in reality: Judeo-Christians would tend to hold to the value that things are done for a purpose due to an underlying principle of perfection (God or God's plan). However, if the internet and its "God/Gods" can be used as examples, what if the underlying perfection doesn't exist. Instead, you have the model scenario that everything "should" be perfect if all things were equal.

 

While site creators have a dream and master plan for themselves and their creations, their users have different one and see the creation in a different light than the creator. In the end, due to lack of shared perception between the creator and user/creation, the end result is imperfection.

 

Just some musings over the nature of the internet with a bit of theological idea over "perfection" and "imperfection".

  • Like 3

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

Very well written, W_ L.  Who else would think to compare an internet site with both religion and drone strikes?

 

I wonder if the hard core straight community would be surprised to know that a gay community has standards of conduct.

Link to comment

Started well - at least the first half of the first sentence - then it was downhill all the way.

No, "the internet" is not a "moral standard". It's just a bunch of wires, servers and other geek stuff  :P

And "rules" and "terms of use" are not "morals". Nor are they "like a religion". And Myr - much as he might wish to be - is not some kinda oiled Greek God, muscles rippling, looking for miscreants to smite :D

And as for the "most people ..." this and "most people ..." that, it's just more fact-free tosh based on ... well, nothing really  :lol:

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Our Privacy Policy can be found here: Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..