Jump to content

Writing Tip: The Indefinite Article


The Indefinite Article

 

 

 

By

 

 

 

andy021278

 

 

 

A daft question: Do I use “A” or “An”?

 


Well it does seem like a daft question doesn’t it, but it’s amazing how many people still struggle with this; especially when confronted by the more obscure grammatical areas such as acronyms and abbreviations?

 

I’ve seen wrong uses in stories posted on line, in published works in print, in newspaper articles and even in professional publications.

 


The basic rule

 


If you had a halfway decent English teacher at school then you will know this rule like the back of your hand. If you had my English teacher, then get ready for a wee shock.

 

Many of us were taught to use “a” in front of a word that begins with a consonant, and “an” in front of a word that begins with a vowel. If you follow this rule and treasure it, then I’m sorry to break this to you, but that only tells half the story.

 

The actual rule is to use “a” in front of a word that begins with a consonant sound, and “an” in front of a word that begins with a vowel sound.

 


Vowels with consonant sounds

 


How can a word that begins with a vowel, possibly begin with a consonant sound?

 

Let’s look at probably the most often used vowel that can have a consonant sound; the letter “u”. If we take two every day words that begin with the letter “u” (uniform and umbrella) and before you read on think about whether you would use “a” or “an” in front of them.

 

If you follow the rule many of us were taught in school, you would use “an” in front of both them. Although “an umbrella” sounds perfectly reasonable, “an uniform” really doesn’t; we use “a uniform”. But why?

 

This is where the vowel sound and the consonant sound comes into play. The word “umbrella” begins with an “um” sound (the sound begins with a vowel, and is therefore called a vowel sound), but the word “uniform” begins with a “you” sound (the sound begins with a consonant, and is therefore called a consonant sound).

 

A few more examples:

 

an oblong (“ob” sound, vowel sound)

 

a one-off (“won” sound, consonant sound)

 

an elephant (“el” sound, vowel sound)

 

a unicorn (“you” sound, consonant sound)

 


Consonants with vowel sounds

 


How can a word that begins with a consonant, possibly begin with a vowel sound?

 

Let’s look at probably the most often used consonant that can have a vowel sound (at least in my opinion), the letter “h”. If we take two everyday words that begin with the letter “h” (hospital and hour), and now before you read on, think about whether you use “a” or “an” in front of them.

 

If you use the rule many of us were taught in school, then you would use “a” in front of both them. Although “a hospital” sounds perfectly reasonable, “a hour” really doesn’t; we use “an hour”. But why?

 

Again, this is where the vowel sound and the consonant sound comes into play. The word “hospital” begins with a “hoh” sound, but the word “hour” begins with an “ow” sound.

 

A few more examples:

 

a hotel (“ho” sound)

 

an honourable person (“on” sound)

 

a xylophone (“zy” sound)

 

an x-ray (“ex” sound)

 


The dreaded letter “h”

 


In spite of how simple this now hopefully sounds to all of you, the “h” words can actually cause a lot of problems.

 

The first thing that causes problems is the simple fact that most people mispronounce the letter “h” as “haitch”, when in fact it is pronounced “aitch”; this causes confusion over the vowel and consonant sounds discussed earlier.

 

The second issue that can cause problems is that the English speaking world is full of what are called “h-droppers”, those who do not pronounce the initial letter “h” in words; an affectation probably most common in Londoners (trust me, I’m guilty of it myself).

 

The third problem stems from the fact that historically in UK English the initial letter “h” was often not pronounced or pronounced very softly (something that was arguably adopted from the French language), and in some cases has persisted into modern times.

 

So for whatever reason, hospital gets pronounced as “ospital”, helpful gets pronounced as “elpful” and so on. All of a sudden, and rather disturbingly, “an hospital” or “an helpful person” sounds right; what is even more disturbing is the fact that my MS Word 2007 grammar checker has not flagged either of these as being incorrect.

 

One particular word, “historic” (and its derivatives such as “historical” and “historically”), is a major bone of contention. The main reason is that most people do not know if it is pronounced “historic” (i.e. the “h” is pronounced) or if it pronounced “istoric” (i.e. it is one of those English words where the “h” is silent, like it is in the word “hour”). It is correctly pronounced as “historic” (I’m talking about in UK English, though “historic” also appears to be correct in American English); so it is always correctly written as “a historic” (and consequently, “a historical” and “a historically”).

 


Abbreviations, initialisms and acronyms

 


The “a” vs “an” rule is exactly the same as with words; it doesn’t make a difference. You use “a” when they start with a consonant sound, and “an” when they start with a vowel sound; you just need to know whether each letter is pronounced separately (an initialism such as CIA), read as a word (an acronym such as NASA), or just read as the actual word (an abbreviation such as etc.). So a few examples are:

 

an FBI agent (“ef” sound, this is an initialism, read as “F B I”)

 

a NASA astronaut (“nah” sound, this is an acronym, and read as “Nasa”)

 

an NHS hospital (“en” sound, this is an initialism, read as “N H S”)

 

a Capt. of the guard (“ka” sound, this is an abbreviation, read as the original word “captain”)

 

a PDF file (“pea” sound, this is an initialism, read as “P D F”)

  • Like 4

13 Comments


Recommended Comments

joann414

Posted

Basics like this can easily make me think too much when I am writing, so I find this very helpful.  But there's a couple of things here that I have not thought about Andy.  Thanks for the info!

  • Like 1
Mann Ramblings

Posted

I think I better PM my editor on this article. I'm not sure how good I am at this. LOL

 

Good information. We all need the English refresher course from time to time.

  • Like 1
Slytherin

Posted

:unsure: thank god I'm not an author :lol:

  • Like 1
LJH

Posted

Not such a daft question after all...

  • Like 1
Low Flyer

Posted

I would agree with you all the way, but I do know many very careful (British) users of English who would insist on "an hotel" and "an historic occasion". This goes back to the French roots of these words where the "h" is not pronounced and, although we now do pronounce the "h", the "an" has remained.

 

And then you get to words such as "herb" which are pronounced differently across the Atlantic. I (as a Scot) would say "a herb garden" whereas I would assume that Americans would say "an herb garden" because Americans generally don't pronounce the initial "h" of "herb".

  • Like 1
Jammi

Posted

Thanks Andy!   that's very helpful :)

  • Like 2
Billy Martin

Posted

Thanks Andy. That's the best it's ever been explained to me.

  • Like 1
Rizan

Posted

I wasn't taught any rules regarding 'a' and 'an' -- I was just taught to say which sounds right.  Thankfully it works 100% of the time.  I never questioned this method until I started seeing people saying 'an historic' as you described.

 

As a side note, there's only one thing that irritates me more than seeing people saying an historic, and that's when people forget to use the last comma while listing.  I don't care what people say about it becoming the norm, it's not okay and it makes no logical sense.

  • Like 2
MikeL

Posted

Thanks, Andy, for a very good explanation.

 

There's another way to view the rule about selecting the article based on the consonant vs. vowel sound of the noun following the article.  Each article/noun combination needs a single consonant sound to separate the two words.  The spoken "a animal" doesn't sound right.  Using "an" supplies the vowel sound where the noun "animal" is missing it at the beginning of the word.  Conversely, "an bear" would be an awkward imposition of an unneeded consonant.

 

A hearing of the words is most important.

 

I agree with you on "a historic" being correct.  The "h" is a consonant with a softer sound than most consonants, but a consonant none the less.

  • Like 1
MJ85

Posted

MS Word 2007 grammar checker: The kind that leaves you having to pick up the slack. :P

  • Like 1
Low Flyer

Posted

I wasn't taught any rules regarding 'a' and 'an' -- I was just taught to say which sounds right.  Thankfully it works 100% of the time.  I never questioned this method until I started seeing people saying 'an historic' as you described.

 

As a side note, there's only one thing that irritates me more than seeing people saying an historic, and that's when people forget to use the last comma while listing.  I don't care what people say about it becoming the norm, it's not okay and it makes no logical sense.

 

Are you talking about the "Oxford comma"? For example, I was taught (about a thousand years ago) to write red, blue and green balloons. With an Oxford comma, that become red, blue, and green balloons. As far as I can see, the only need for this would be if there was any possibility of confusion - perhaps some of the balloons are blue and green. In this case, that's just not possible so the comma is unnecessary.

Fishwings

Posted

Are you talking about the "Oxford comma"? For example, I was taught (about a thousand years ago) to write red, blue and green balloons. With an Oxford comma, that become red, blue, and green balloons. As far as I can see, the only need for this would be if there was any possibility of confusion - perhaps some of the balloons are blue and green. In this case, that's just not possible so the comma is unnecessary.

 

It's just safer to always put it in. A lot of the times you won't notice that it doesn't make logical sense coz it makes sense in your mind.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...