Hi Cia, as you know by now I read and review whilst listening to music. During the course of reading your novel, I listened to some LIVE stuff, like Heaven, and I Walk The Line and Nobody Knows - all good stuff doe the age group you are writing about, but, as it so happened, as I got to and into the accident scene ( and subsequent hospital scenes), the most beautiful music played for me, Adagio For Strings, OP 11 - Eugene Ormandy conducting the Philadelphia Orchestra. Your writing, and this music, blew me away.
It dawned on me, this is a sad tale of loss, a tale of joy, a tale of courage and discovery. Whenever sorrow comes home to one of us, and Tap is in touch with Dane's sorrow, you (the writer) are aware that we pride ourselves upon the opposite conduct. that is, we glory in being able to endure calmness, because, in our estimation, this behaviour called calmness, is manly. Tap feels this behaviour. He is calm, to a point, and logical. This is what makes him more of a man than Dane or even Tap's own father.
In every day life, we have calamities of our own, but in Dane's case, his troubles are forced upon him. He hungers for the calmness, so he indulges in the privelege of weeping and bewailing himself because it is nature to covet this satisfaction. And, in the case of love, and anger, and all the mental sensations of desire, grief and pleasure which your characters aspire to, your writing waters and cherishes these emotions. You satisfy the link between trhe tragic emotions of pity and fear, and Tap is the cathartic instrument for Dane. The emotion of pity in your work is not to be confused with crass sentimentality. Violence is not crass. Dane's tragic protagonist is not a pitiful figure, his father is. And he comes across as a cowering derelict, if this was your intention, you have succeeded admirably. Throughout this work, the element of empathy is central. This reader enjoyed a vicarious experience with your tragic protagonist and your hero in Tap. Fear is also experienced vicariously, the fear that some of us may some day be in Dane's position.
I'm not going to elucidate on points of story telling here. Those I keep for the struggling writer. In any event, there is no need to discourse upon those elements. You have mastered them. But don't stop, we all lose something along the way. For now, I am satisfied that you took me on a journey, and in story telling, the journey is the most important aspect.
This tale is well told, (there are gremlins but these you will see and expunge), and deserves accolades.
Until next time
Louis J