Mea culpa!
Stay tuned to find out
Maybe it is my police experience, but people seem to take too much at face value what people say. People are the most unbelievable witnesses. That includes myself! We once were six officers attending a scene and we wrote our statements and then checked. Gosh, they were different...
The sergeant mentioning those people might be a complete red herring. First of all they might have not been gay at all, so no harem. Second even if they were or not, they might have absolutely nothing to do with any of this.
But no, I doubt he missed a left leg, because the sergeant would have mentioned such an identifiable mark. Maybe I am not getting a reference here ... sorry.
Nope, worse. A PS I once met.