Abortion: part 2
I would like to clarify that when I posted the previous blog I was highly frustrated for having been chewed out just previously for having an opinion on the issue at all. I have various reasons to be indignant about the events transpiring in that situation, but they're ultimately irrelevant to the issue of abortion and merely relate to the irrationality of the person I was misfortunate enough to speak near.
In spite of that person's protest that as a man I don't have a right to an opinion on the issue, as someone interested in public policy and planning to make a career in that field, I don't have the luxury of not having an opinion on the issue.
The opinion I do have on the issue was rather hastily written in the previous blog, but again, to clarify, my opinion is two-fold, one on what the current policy should be given current circumstances, and the second part concerning what circumstances should be striven toward in order to make way for a more amicable policy.
I'm not going to hide the fact that I don't like the concept of abortion. I also recognize that the decision to have an abortion is not an easy one and for the vast majority of women who undergo the procedure they have many very serious concerns which led them to it. From a policy perspective, I'm disinclined to seek to make abortion simply illegal; now or ever. Rather, at present I would leave it legal, but I would implement such policies as to reduce the frequency of unwanted pregnancies and in time seek to implement laws to regulate the process of allowing an abortion to take place.
To start, a greater public emphasis on family planning through birth control and especially the morning after pill. I have talked to so many people who either were unaware of the morning after pill or had been deceived into thinking it is an abortion pill that its appalling. A public which is well educated on means of birth control and not cornered into the abstinence only nonsense the present administration pushes is key to cutting down on the number of abortions.
The next step policy-wise would be to make it easier for women with unwanted pregnancies to make the decision to bring the baby to term. The first step (as I see it) to doing this is to reform child services so that its a viable alternative rather than the embarrassment that it is. Health care reforms so as to minimize the financial burdens are also necessary. I'm certain there are other things which could be done to make it easier on mothers with unwanted pregnancies to decide to bring the baby to term, but I think you can see where I'm going with this. I would also oppose any policy seeking to create disincentives to abortion rather than incentives to birth.
Whether, should the reforms I speak of be made and the demand for abortions drops dramatically, abortion should then be made illegal... I don't think making it illegal would be appropriate, considering that whatever may be the case in normative society exceptions always abound... but where I think making it illegal outright inappropriate, I also think a consultation and approval by a review board of some form would be appropriate.
I realize some of these positions will be found more agreeable than others, but I think it involves the right amount of compromise to be workable. On the one hand, the frequency of abortions will decline significantly - something the pro-lifers would applaud if we assume they have any integrity whatsoever, and the ability to have an abortion when needed is still preserved, which should appease the pro-choicers. I consider this a reasonable solution to a complicated issue.
Yet, reasonable as I may consider it to be, any such policies would face serious opposition by pro-lifers who are more interested in just stopping people from having sex because their religion scares them into thinking sex is immoral if its not for the explicit purpose of trying to create a child... and on the other side, there are many people who will oppose anything short of on-demand abortions and will see any policy aiming at reducing the demand for abortions as being a threat to the ability to have abortions period.
The middle path is not an easy road... more of a gauntlet on this issue.
5 Comments
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now