Old Bob, I would love to respond to this survey, but I can't. The first question doesn't have an option that I can agree with, and the second question doesn't have an option for someone who has stories posted here at GA. Since I didn't select an option, the system doesn't accept my vote
As for the last question, my vote is for No. I find grading authors becomes a popularity contest, rather than a quality question. Authors in niche genres, such as historical, horror, science fiction, fantasy, etc., don't stand a chance in general. There just wouldn't be enough readers to praise the quality. The only way it could be close to fair is to have a group of impartial judges, which would be very, very difficult to manage in a purely volunteer environment like GA.