Jump to content

Mattyboy

Author
  • Posts

    1,232
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Mattyboy

  1. Mattyboy

    Chapter 22

    They seem extraordinarily useless in general (and in this particular case, it doesn't seem like they could have anything to offer).
  2. Mattyboy

    Chapter 17

    Well done, JJ. Flawed, but working with a high degree of difficulty.
  3. Mattyboy

    Chapter 16

    hehe “Hey, your mom started it.” Dr Dull is writing a pretty big cheque when he keeps saying he'll be responsible for Travigiovanni fallout.
  4. Mattyboy

    Chapter 11

    Just from the neighborhood he seems to live in (and that frosty-tentacle business) it seems sensible to be wary of Oblivion. But Prometheus definitely has some coming clean to do.
  5. Mattyboy

    Chapter 6

    Prometheus had bird trouble, but not with a phoenix.
  6. Mattyboy

    Chapter 4

    Poor JJ. "Hell is other people."
  7. Mattyboy

    Chapter 1

    Only you would know
  8. Mattyboy

    Chapter 1

    mm, more you could develop the thought. He's proud of how he did at 112 as a freshman, but how about at 150 as a sophomore? 112 is a small 14 yr old, and 185 is a big 17 yr old. 113lbs is the second smallest (to 106) weight class in WV HS, and 190 is the third biggest (215 &285). (They change the classes often enough this doesn't even count as an anachronism, it was 182 and 195 in 2021). Lots of boys have teen growth spurts. 6" - 70 lbs in 3 years is a big one, but its no rarer than green eyes, and it's your character. But as a wrestler, he's been through nine weight classes in three years. It's something he'd mention (and you touch on it, Greg says he wants to stay at 185). And yup on the bullies - if you're telling us he's smart enough to know it's not safe for him to be out (and he seems pretty together) then I'll take it that he knows his school.
  9. Mattyboy

    Chapter 1

    Yep, interesting start. State wrestling champ at 185 and worried about bullies is a bit odd. Not that jerks couldn't attack him, but good wrestlers usually have a LOT of body confidence. 112 to 185 is a huge jump. People grow a lot in high school alright, but wow!
  10. Mattyboy

    Chapter 11

    Well, Sam should do that then! I see you've been off working on other fun and fabulous ideas (which is great, too), but these characters deserve an ending! Glad that they got Glen out, though.
  11. Mattyboy

    The Sorest Spot

    Well, that's interesting with John. And August! 🤞
  12. Mattyboy

    Chapter 1

    Hehe. This is fun.
  13. Mattyboy

    Chapter 16

    Yep, this feels like peak chaos and maybe an inflection point. But Ronyx named this story for the chaos, so I guess we'll see if he can crank it up another turn!
  14. Mattyboy

    Epilogue

    Well, I just got here, and read through after you posted the epi. I have a few nitpicks (do teenage boys in Nebraska call each other "mate"?), but I thought the overall set up and story are great and pretty intriguing. There's always DMs. (Especially re Sean and Mal, who feel tailored; if Patrick was just an off-the-rack high school bully, that's a perfectly good ending).
  15. Mattyboy

    Batch 47

    Ugh, I was pointed in the right direction on "Chad" recognizing the room number, and then sidestepped off into "completely wrong." The way you wrote River's recovery from the early shocks and pain to "LaDon and the guys came in like a pack of mother wolves" is pretty amazing writing. Gano is wonderful. The idea that you know the the guy is into you when you see the portrait they drew is pretty standard stuff around here. Gano is all that plus very fresh and funny and very current. And it's so fun that anthro/fur works so well crossing the gaps between the art-school guys and the sportsbros. 🦏 If you find (or become) the artist for this, can 2-slot go to LaDon and the boys as a pack of wolves? 🐺🐺🤕🐺🐺
  16. Mattyboy

    Epilogue

    I feel this epilogue needs an expansion pack or something. Excellent twist, but what about the other loose ends? I'm into these characters, but I HAVE QUESTIONS 1) Sean: is the rainbow flag for him? or his Dad(s)? Will we see him at the march, with Dad(s) and/or Josh and Levi? 2) Mal: an outsider for some reason? or just the ordinary quiet kid that grew into a hottie under the nose of the locals? is he into Jordy for himself, or as a stepping stone to Shannon? 3) Patrick: mayor's kid is a violent goth-punk? that's weird. And why so angry? 4) Monica: can she grow into a real friend and a high-school jungle guide?
  17. Mattyboy

    Point of View

    Sorry 'bout that @Dan South. But it's not as spoiled as you think.
  18. Mattyboy

    Point of View

    ugh, poor Wren. I get why he wanted to go back to the familiar, but new Wren had a chance at the life and energy he seemed to hunger for.
  19. Mattyboy

    Batch 46

    or a rhino! 🦏🦛🐻
  20. Mattyboy

    Batch 46

    Nah, he's been invited to the room and he'd recognized the address. But intrigued with the idea it's someone we've met
  21. "One last time" sounds good. Unless it's bad. Argh!
  22. Mattyboy

    Chapter 54

    I liked this. I was taking it (and that last line) as showing us that Tom had remembered (learned?) how be happy again. (and that Taylan and Dana knew the old Tom well enough to pick something he'd like).
  23. Mattyboy

    Batch 45

    Will we get the Gano pic? Kristin is quite right, of course. Good for the bros being mutually supportive.
  24. Mattyboy

    Chapter 31

    Yep, Mom's next. But this feels like some progress and Ethan has some momentum now.
  25. Mattyboy

    Batch 44

    Excellent fun. Gav doesn't seem judgy, little River will keep on rollin'.
×
×
  • Create New...