I'm sort of both but in different areas.
When you go into my bedroom, the bed isn't made, my exercise stuff is roughly bunched in the corner, and the chess board is in the last position it was in when I was playing with against myself the night before. My study room will probably be as messy with my school books spread out on the table.
It is almost the opposite though for the living room, the kitchen, my closet, or the bookshelves. The living room is always arranged in a specific way: two pillows on the right side of the sofa, a pillow on the loveseat, three books and a magazine on the lower level of the coffee table, and a centerpiece on top. The kitchen is always clean unless somebody just finished cooking. My clothes in the closet are arranged by color and type. All shirts, tshirts, and hoodies are are separated and arranged by color. Same goes with my jackets and formal wear. The novels that I have bought and finished reading are grouped together and neatly placed on the shelves downstairs. If I haven't finished it yet, it will be stacked in my bedroom according to size.
So yeah. It is a mix.