You are very kind to offer such encouraging words. You chose two of my favorite bits to include in your quote, which made me grin. If the dialogue in this chapter is good, it's only because I tried to pay attention to other excellent writers on GA. They provided the very kind of instruction you speak of, and they can smile that you think the student did relatively well here. I agree that dialogue can be hard to write sometimes. From time to time, I have had to rip out whole sections and try again, because it just sounded forced or lifeless to my ear. I have no doubt that this is true for other writers, too. Thank you so very much for your comments and for reading!