I don't think I have a preference, as long as it's well-written. The TV series The Sinner is a perfect example of both styles. I've only seen seasons two and three, but they are quite disparate in how they reveal the mystery. Each season is successful in drawing the viewer into an intricate tale with plenty of suspense. I think there definitely needs to be red herrings and some element of surprise thrown in, otherwise it's boring if the writer feeds the reader all the clues.