Personally I never got the impression that this was a first story. From the first chapter I was breathless and swept away with what was written, how it was written and how what was written was affecting me. It made my heart beat faster, my mind race down all the avenues opened up and to be frank my stomach sink at the possibilities, the inevitabilities and the fact the way that it was presented as being so very possibly our own future.
In some way the sexual aspect was irrelevant to the actual story, although I can't deny it was one of the elements that made my pulses race. The real strengths of the story were
1. the general air of foreboding.
2. the almost palpable fear that permeates most of the story
3. the obvious degeneration of the society that back it as is made clear with their readiness to push more and more people through the system and to, if not blatanty lie then at least misrepresent the actual process.
4. the nature of the society who are ready, willing and eager to accept the slide that leads to the development of the machine in the first place.
5. the mechanics of how it all works which are detailed, in cases explicit and well thought through.
6. the fact that there is very little description. We don't even get the Attendant's name until right at the end
7 the flashes of humanity shown by the Attendance as his disillusion with the process grows throughout the story.
8 the way that the story unfolds in the background of the description of the process.
9. how each character who become part of the weave of the story has their own background and stories to tell and grow in their own individual ways, and they are very distinct and different but again there is little actual description of them.
10 the fact that each character who is followed through to the end find their own way of adapting and ultimately finding ways of going Against the Machine, some more radical than others.
As to whether the Machine is just a machine. There were hints and suggestions all the way through
.
I think that the story has real cohesion in that it creates a world then continually drops in new details about the ways in which that world operates and changes. Nothing is set in stone and the sand beneath your feet is constantly shifting.
This is a truly unique story that is readable over and over because like all the best story every time you read it you see new things you never saw before.
My favourite character is the Attendant who is inimitably human... and Noah who is so sweet and innocent of the whole thing.
Chilling, exciting, ennervating, innovative. One of my favourite stories of all time. (as far as this site is concerned at least. Sorry but you can't compare to Storm Constantine yet) and likely to remain that way for a very very long time. It appeals to my twisted mind in an incredibly forceful way and I will remember it for a long time.