I just hit the 'Like' button when I really wanted to press 'Angry.' I self-censored because I thought that when I got down here to the comments I'd find a bunch of nicer-than-me folks being too damned understanding. But, of course, your story required, and exemplifies, a deeply empathetic understanding. At least I have the satisfaction of imagining a short life for Jim in prison.
Most folks, including me, attribute Sarah's distance to her sick attachment to an abuser, but maybe it's shame and guilt? Naw--I scrolled back up and saw that her silence started after the guys pressed charges (which a prosecutor would have done anyway.)
Finally, forgive me for being obtuse, but have the guys forgone sex for over a year? I could understand if rape were involved, but this indicates to me that they have some deep resentment to one another--or at least Elliot towards Grant.
Great story--evokes strong emotions.