I think that it is a sign of the quality of Andy’s writing that has provoked an interesting discussion. Very thought-provoking. Well done @andy cannon! You are a very welcome contributor here!
I so agree with you, Peter. As a professional medieval historian I dared to disagree with an “academic” non-fiction piece on this site, which was, in my opinion, imposing a gay/queer agenda on a society 2,000 yrs ago. I wrote in measured, Oxonian prose. My goodness, the reply was vitriolic. I was to gather and accept my role in the persecution and killing of centuries of gays. I blocked the person to never have to read his pseudo intellectual comments again. To read here a measured, wise comment has restored my faith. Thank you. I thought it was perhaps only me.