Jump to content

Writing Tip: Writing Groups - Some Pros And Cons


Trebs

1,113 views

We wouldn't be able to produce and provide all of the wonderful content here at the GA News Blog without so many great contributors. Libby Drew gives us a great tip for authors on Writing Groups. Enjoy!

 

 

 


Writing Groups: Some Pros and Cons

 


A writing group can do wonders for our motivation and keep us accountable for our production. Members cheer us on, understand how even the smallest recognition can mean the world, and know not to say things like, “Oh, you’re a writer? Do you have any bestsellers?”

 

There are pros and cons to using writing groups. Here are a few.

 

Benefits:

  • Writers of the same genre may have a helpful understanding of voice and target audience. Writers of different genres offer fresh opinions.
  • Reading other people's fiction and trying to articulate a critique of that fiction increases our understanding of the way storytelling works. Further, other members may point out things we wouldn't normally notice. This process helps us develop a critical eye, specifically in regards to our own craft.
  • Every writer is different. We use different routines, tools, and work spaces. Talking with other writers is a great way to expose ourselves to alternative processes. We may learn tricks that help us write better or use time more efficiently.


Pitfalls:

  • Writing groups can be a waste of time if the members are writing at different levels. Novice writers might be left behind while more experienced writers may not receive the level of critique they need. While the flattery will feel nice, it won’t help them improve.
  • Bad advice is rampant. That it’s unintentional doesn’t make it any less harmful. Writing group peers are not all-knowing, nor are they (most of the time) well-established professionals.
  • The writing group becomes happy hour. Like-minded people have the potential to become our close friends. Meetings can easily become social events. Enjoying being a writer is fine, but being a writer also means, you know, writing.
  • Editing and critiquing can take a lot of free time. Some editing is good and will increase the quality of our own writing, but if all our time is taken up by editing, we’re learning how to be editors, not writers.


And here’s one that can go on both the pro and con list: Writing groups are honest and critical.

 


We all want to hear that our writing is good. Nobody puts their creation out there hoping to hear that it’s not. Some writers claim they don’t care what other people think, but with very, very rare exception, they’re lying. When our peers, and quite often they become our friends, tell us what doesn't work, it hurts. We have to develop a thick skin if we want to improve. A critique of our writing is not a critique of us as individuals. Writing may be more of an art than other tasks, but it’s still very much a learned skill.

 

And, with caveats, a writing group is a learning tool.

 

~Libby

  • Like 5

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

I have used writing groups in the past and can agree with all Libby pointed out. I have worked with mixed groups where the writers were at similar writing abilities, but all wrote in different genres. That was both good and bad. Offering fresh perspectives, yet having issues because while one understands romance the world of sci-fi was unknown. The historical drama author and the urban feminist couldn't find common ground. While the notes from each author on your story were insightful, they weren't always helpful. A good group should have a general understanding of the stories being written, be honest, and be willing to challenge the author if they find problems.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

This is some really good information.  I've never worked on a group project before but I have just signed up for a group writing project.  I'm really excited since it's something new.  I'll have to keep your tips in mind when we get underway to avoid getting sidetracted :P

  • Like 2
Link to comment

I have never worked in writing groups. I normally avoid doing so because my own writing habits are very erratic. I don't commit to anything, especially if it involves someone else's work too. Working with someone different is good- you get to learn stuff. Working with someone too different can only lead to incompatibility issues. Who you are working with is something to consider, I think.

 

By the way, I love the last paragraph. Very true! And very well-said.

 

Great article, Libby. Thanks for the share. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Our Privacy Policy can be found here: Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..