As long as we are pointing out Andy's foibles, I believe Robert was also a bit lacking, for someone who had a background serving his country, he also was instrumental in guiding Andy as he delved deeper into this matter....I guess what has me cranky is that everyone who knew about Matt's arrival with the exception of Maeve, dropped the proverbial ball, stepped onto a flaming bag of dog poo, forgot to put his parachute on before jumping out of the plane...
What we don't know was, what was so gosh durned critical that Andy just had to leave the island, more so I have to believe that given where he lives that he would have been aware of the weather as a matter of course...
Reactions are what any great story should engender, and boy oh boy...kudos to you for pressing my flapjacks, fiddlesticks, and folderol button....you almost hit the cheese and crackers alarm!!!!