Site Moderator TalonRider Posted June 25, 2008 Site Moderator Posted June 25, 2008 Depending upon how close Steve was to the rock face on his way down, he could have grabbed onto a bush or something growing out of it. Farfecthed I know, but you never know what CJ's got up his sleeve to get out of trouble. As for New York City, maybe J/S has a favorite restaurant there that serves goat.
Benji Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Depending upon how close Steve was to the rock face on his way down, he could have grabbed onto a bush or something growing out of it. Farfecthed I know, but you never know what CJ's got up his sleeve to get out of trouble. As for New York City, maybe J/S has a favorite restaurant there that serves goat. ......Steve didn't just fall over, a concussion grenade knocked him over, there is probably a good chance he is unconscious and unless by a miracle his body is trapped by a bush on the way down. I fear he is dead. Brandon may be able to 'push' off of Dimitri and save his own skin by making a grab at the cliff (personally I like the idea of him hitting an unsuspecting goat, and replacing the goats spot)
MikeL Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 Is that because heavier objects fall faster? :wacko: I'm surprised that an engineering student would make such a statement. Average velocity va of an object that has been falling for time t (averaged over time): va=
Benji Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Average velocity va of an object that has been falling for time t (averaged over time): va=
MikeL Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 Average velocity va of an object that has been falling for time t (averaged over time): va=
Bondwriter Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 ........Regardless of weight? In a vacuum maybe, but a feather and a rock, no! Two bodies offer a similar resistance to air, I'd say, unless the surface of Dimitri exposed to air is significantly different from this of Brandon. But Brandon's odds to catch a tree growing out from the cliff, or to fall 5 feet below on a small platform are higher from a fictional point of view. What makes the odds higher is that the author is not at risk of ending on a spit if Dimitri equals the performance of Franz Reichelt.
Tiger Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 (edited) It really does not take a rocket scientist to figure out that the chances of survival are slim to none. I suppose we'll just have to wait and find out. Edited June 25, 2008 by Tiger
Benji Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Two bodies offer a similar resistance to air, I'd say, unless the surface of Dimitri exposed to air is significantly different from this of Brandon. But Brandon's odds to catch a tree growing out from the cliff, or to fall 5 feet below on a small platform are higher from a fictional point of view. What makes the odds higher is that the author is not at risk of ending on a spit if Dimitri equals the performance of Franz Reichelt. :wacko: .......Franz, the 1st Darwin recipient? Dimitri's death will not save the goat from the spit if Brandon fails to save himself.
Bondwriter Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 :wacko: .......Franz, the 1st Darwin recipient? Dimitri's death will not save the goat from the spit if Brandon fails to save himself. I think he'd have won the Darwin award indeed. I'd encourage everyone to watch the video of Franz's feat. It should make you laugh and shudder at the same time. Notice how he hesitates because of the media presence. I can see the thoughts whirling inside his head: "Will I chicken out? Well, all these people have come for me... At the same time, what if my invention doesn't work?" And indeed, Brandon will have to be saved from the Great Goat Peril. CJ has more power over Brandon's life than Dimitri.
Benji Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 I think he'd have won the Darwin award indeed. I'd encourage everyone to watch the video of Franz's feat. It should make you laugh and shudder at the same time. Notice how he hesitates because of the media presence. I can see the thoughts whirling inside his head: "Will I chicken out? Well, all these people have come for me... At the same time, what if my invention doesn't work?" And indeed, Brandon will have to be saved from the Great Goat Peril. CJ has more power over Brandon's life than Dimitri. ......How is the goat going to manage to wiggle out of this one??
C James Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 CJ, you know that I don't comment often your chapters. I have no questions about what happened or will happen, neither to admire all your cliffhangers because its always an evidence that you are the king of them .But this time, I want to say you never wrote a best chapter ; a model of action, a thriller for itself, the fighters exchanging their acts like first class tennis players in a "Grand Chlem"! Each phrase coming just when needed, each character kept going as he should, with the reader out of breath. overwhelmed . Good work done. I suppose the pressure will even climb more till the end. I can't waite of the next chapter Hi Old Bob!!! Thank you! This is my first try at a running battle, so figuring out how to get the back-and forth right without slowing it down or making it confusing took me a little time. Thanks!!! ........Ah, for once there is no cliffhanger....there was nothing to hang on to!! I'm puzzled!! I had no idea Dimitri was a superb pitcher, I mean throwing a grenade from fifty feet inside a mine shaft to the mines entrance is quite a feat!! Brandon will survive, he was closer to the edge from the impact of Dimitri's body, he will most likely land on some goat on a ledge...sending the poor misunderstood creature over and most likely landing on a startled Russian. The very best chapter of all, Great job CJ...BTW Author's Note: Please forgive the slightly tense chapter ending, but the story is coming to an end (2 more chapters and an epilogue that will be posted with the final chapter). The remaining text is already in editing so it should be posted on schedule. Also, the chapter would have had a tense ending no matter where I cut it at this point. .....A LITTLE TENSE??????? Benji, thank your for your declaration of "no Cliffhanger".. You are, of course, correct. Brandon is not hanging from a cliff, so no cliffhanger. Also, Brandon is fine! Just a few scratches (that happens when you charge through an old mine shirtless) and that minor bullet crease. Granted, he has a little gravitational issue.... BTW, do you think I over-stated things by calling it "a little tense"? You might be right! Maybe I should re-phrase... Perhaps "a slight trace of possible unease"? I guess it's a good thing the next chapter isn't named "Impact"... Er, oh, well, it is, but for that, we have to blame shadowgod... At least I did not give in to the Evil One's demand that I name it "Splat"... Now I know why people talk about lynching the goat. Very. Cruel. Eagerly awaiting the next one... Who? Me? I'm not cruel... And I think forum opinion has moved away from lynchi8ng ant towards open-spit roasting.. Brandon might come out of this badly hurt, but I agree with everyone else that he would land on Dimitri. Being the larger and heavier person, Dimitri would land first if Brandon holds on to him. The rocks at the base of the slope would not make for the softest of landings. However, I can say without a doubt that the fall would not be fatal... Falls are NEVER fatal. The sudden stop at the bottom might well be, but the fall itself is never fatal. Okay, for some general comments from me; the acceleration rate of gravity is 33 feet per second, per second. A dropped object will travel 33 feet in it's first second, 66 in second #2, 99 feet in the third second, etc. However, that's without air resistance. Terminal velocity for a free-falling human is, at sea level, about 125 mph. I don't give an altitude in the text, but the mountains east of Last Dollar road have areas like the one I describe at about 9500 feet. The air is thinner, so less resistance, hence faster terminal velocity. Going from memory (always a bad idea for me) but at that altitude, air density (and thus drag) are about 55% of at sea level. So, as a ballpark figure, say 50% less drag and increase terminal V by 50%. That would make it roughly 185 mph. Of course, that's very rough, and many things can change; assuming a head or feet down position lowers drag and increases velocity. In a vacuum, a feather and a hammer do indeed fall at the same rate. Dimitri and Brandon would fall at roughly the same rate, though the determining factor here would be air friction; Brandon might fall slightly faster due to less drag (he's shirtless). BTW, if anyone is curious what happens, the clues are in Ch 45.
Tiger Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 CJ, he was copy/pasting what you posted at the end of the chapter. Since the last several chapters (I've lost count) have ended with evil cliffhangers, it is now becoming expected. Only one other author on GA (sorry Steve not you) has ever had so many evil cliffhangers in succession, and yours are much more devious than his. Why don't you just admit that you are, and will always be, the undisputed King of Evil Cliffhangers. We all know you are the only one truly worthy of the title.
Site Administrator wildone Posted June 26, 2008 Site Administrator Posted June 26, 2008 <br />CJ, he was copy/pasting what you posted at the end of the chapter. Since the last several chapters (I've lost count) have ended with evil cliffhangers, it is now becoming expected. Only one other author on GA (sorry Steve not you) has ever had so many evil cliffhangers in succession, and yours are much more devious than his. Why don't you just admit that you are, and will always be, the undisputed King of Evil Cliffhangers. We all know you are the only one truly worthy of the title. <img src="https://www.gayauthors.org/forums/style_emoticons/default/worshippy.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=" " border="0" alt="worshippy.gif" /><br /><br /><br /><br /> I am in full agreement Tim. Maybe we need to upgade his name to "sovereign emperor of evil cliffhangers for life" What do you think?
Tiger Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 <br /><br /><br /> I am in full agreement Tim. Maybe we need to upgade his name to "sovereign emperor of evil cliffhangers for life" What do you think? Well, unless Steve can somehow top CJ's evil cliffhanging mastery, I do think the title is worth consideration.
C James Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 CJ, he was copy/pasting what you posted at the end of the chapter. Since the last several chapters (I've lost count) have ended with evil cliffhangers, it is now becoming expected. Only one other author on GA (sorry Steve not you) has ever had so many evil cliffhangers in succession, and yours are much more devious than his. Why don't you just admit that you are, and will always be, the undisputed King of Evil Cliffhangers. We all know you are the only one truly worthy of the title. But, but, but... there was no cliffhanger in this chapter! Brandon isn't even touching the cliff at the chapter end!! <br /><br /><br /> I am in full agreement Tim. Maybe we need to upgade his name to "sovereign emperor of evil cliffhangers for life" What do you think? ACK!! But, but, need i remind you all of Shadowgod's LiS 26? OK, a serious question; Dimitri's Grenade Toss. In the chapter he tossed it 50 feet, sort of; it was depicted as bouncing when it came out of the shaft. So, he had to toss it at least 40 feet. The problem here is the shaft roof; I don't specify it, but given the descriptions it's about eight feet. So, he can't lob it up. There's a somewhat similar shaft between me and town (horizonal, like the one in the story), so I stopped by this afternoon. I used an old and battered plastic flashlight that's a bit harder to throw, and stood at the shaft mouth (about five feet back). I clicked on the flashlight and chucked it in. I can't be quite sure how far it went; the light went out as soon as it hit. As a guess, fifty feet, but I have no real idea, and I have no intention of going in and looking (old Mine shafts are dangerous, I almost never go in them). I tried to look in using a handheld spotlight, but couldn't see well enough, and there's rubble on the floor in places. I then tried chucking a full can of soda at a tree. The soda can is a decent approximation of a cylindrical concussion grenade in size and weight. I pegged the tree at fifty feet, about two feet abbove the ground (and three feet below my aim point) and soda went everywhere. A tree trunk is smaller than a mine shaft mouth by quite a lot (this tree is about three feet wide, a shaft would be seven or eight. A baseball pitcher stands 60 feet from home plate, but they need to get the ball over the plate at high speed. Demitri didn't. BUT, unless there's some decent speed, it would need to be lofted and the shaft roof would preclude that. My feeling, based on all this, is that Dimitri, if he had any experience whatsoever throwing a ball or a graende, could have made it to the needed 40 feet. However, my test was IMHO noninclusive. Anyone have any feelings on this, or test ideas? BTW, I won't entertain any suggestions that involve me going into the mineshaft.
Dion Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 It would be something like bowling in an alley, would it not?
BeaStKid Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 Nice chapter, CJ. Now be a sweet goat and let Dmitri be the cushion and break Brandon's fall. I think the chapter's name, Sacrifice, hints that Steve may be...... DAMN!! BeaStKid
Drewbie Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 (edited) So So So So, you are saying Steve's dead Who's going to counsel Wilde? Edited June 26, 2008 by Drewbie
MikeL Posted June 26, 2008 Author Posted June 26, 2008 (edited) In a vacuum, a feather and a hammer do indeed fall at the same rate. Dimitri and Brandon would fall at roughly the same rate, though the determining factor here would be air friction; Brandon might fall slightly faster due to less drag (he's shirtless). BTW, if anyone is curious what happens, the clues are in Ch 45. Clues from chapter 45: After a quick meeting, the hasty plan was put into motion. The Shadows dropped back over the edge and began paralleling the trail fifty feet below its level. There are some places along the mountainside where a person can stand...or break a fall. The Shadows, with Zeke in the lead, worked their way along, traversing the mountainside. Most of it was easy enough, but in some places nearly vertical escarpments and the bases of flat-topped spires blocked their paths. Some could be worked around, but others required free-climb traverses, and the steepness of the slope increased the further north they moved. They had no ropes, no safety gear, and compounding the risk was the need to stay silent and covert. Every so often they would stop, and Wilde would check upslope and to the north, trying to spot their quarry. After many frantic minutes, they came to an area of steep mine tailings, badly eroded, which clung to the mountainside. Wilde and Steve shared a knowing look as Wilde whispered, Edited June 26, 2008 by MikeL
Benji Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 Clues from chapter 45: There are some places along the mountainside where a person can stand...or break a fall. Easy? </B> Bushes and saddles twenty feet down. There are several possibilities for Brandon to stop his fall. .........rough talus!!! It makes a hell of a slide, if you have ever traversed down the side of a mountain where the tailings of a mine have been dumped. If Brandon & Dimitri encounter this at twenty feet, they will both survive, very cut up, both survivable.
C James Posted June 27, 2008 Posted June 27, 2008 A couple of thoughts on the title, "Blood and Sacrifice". What does Brandon believe, based on his thoughts about Chase right before the leap? Saving millions of people, at the willing cost of his own life? It would be something like bowling in an alley, would it not? Sort of... I checked by googling, and a bowling lane is about 60 ft, but Dimitri would have had to keep the grenade airborn about 40, so about 2/3 of a bowline alley length. That's a very good way of visualizing it though; think of hurling a full can of soda (which is about the right size, shape and mass) 2/3 to 3/4 of the way down a bowling alley.
Benji Posted June 27, 2008 Posted June 27, 2008 A couple of thoughts on the title, "Blood and Sacrifice". What does Brandon believe, based on his thoughts about Chase right before the leap? Saving millions of people, at the willing cost of his own life? ........Very noble!! The second sacrifice is up to the readers, no? Sort of... I checked by googling, and a bowling lane is about 60 ft, but Dimitri would have had to keep the grenade airborn about 40, so about 2/3 of a bowline alley length. That's a very good way of visualizing it though; think of hurling a full can of soda (which is about the right size, shape and mass) 2/3 to 3/4 of the way down a bowling alley. .........So you lost the flashlight? Did you bring along a tape measure to try and gage how far it went in?
W_L Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 .........rough talus!!! It makes a hell of a slide, if you have ever traversed down the side of a mountain where the tailings of a mine have been dumped. If Brandon & Dimitri encounter this at twenty feet, they will both survive, very cut up, both survivable. Glad to hear that Brandon has a chance at life, but Dimitri will be alive, too. I want Dimitri to be tortured for information for some reason; it just feels right to me for what he has done to Chase and all the people he killed and tried to kill.
Bondwriter Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 Glad to hear that Brandon has a chance at life, but Dimitri will be alive, too. I want Dimitri to be tortured for information for some reason; it just feels right to me for what he has done to Chase and all the people he killed and tried to kill. It is entirely up to CJ to have Brandon safe and Dimitri fall. Personally, the mere fact that Dimitri is out of the way is enough to make my day. A slow and painful death would just be a cherry on the top.
Site Administrator wildone Posted June 28, 2008 Site Administrator Posted June 28, 2008 It is entirely up to CJ to have Brandon safe and Dimitri fall. Personally, the mere fact that Dimitri is out of the way is enough to make my day. A slow and painful death would just be a cherry on the top. So your day would be made with Dimitri dead, even if Brandon was dead too? Back to the sacrifice thing..... Brandon has always felt that he wasn't good enough for Chase. You think about all the scenes where he was willing to sacrifice himself without giving thought of his relationship as he has always felt that he had nothing really to contribute, unlike what he felt Chase could. Were these clues to prepare us for Brandon's death in the story? I would say that if he is dead, CJ could tell us that he foreshadowed it by Brandon's actions up to this point. The goat is evil that way
Recommended Posts