Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I can't watch the video either. I copied the lyrics from the internet and spent a couple of hours composing :)

 

The Oracle

Thanks for taking the challenge! I feared no one would be game for this one, but so far so good with the responses. 

 

I like the somber and rather musical lilt to your poem. I think it is perfect for a classical musical setting. Good job!

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Here's my attempt at this, poetry is not really my thing (and certainly not rhymes), so I wanted to try the challenge

 

https://www.gayauthors.org/story/craftingmom/attemptsatpoetry/1

I just love to hear that you decided to take the challenge precisely because it is challenging. I am the same way :)

 

The way your poem flows is very good to me. I love how you seemed to capture the indecision and faltering stop-and-go at the beginning, and then that becomes overrun by excitement and free-flowing ideas as the poem comes to a climax. Really nice - I hope decide to stick with it and try some more rhymes!   

Link to comment

Here's mine.

 

It... got a little dark:o

 

Edit: and you know what, on looking it over, I see I pretty much abandoned meter. I'll need to take another shot at it.

 

Edit: Ok, I listened to the piece quite a number of times, carefully keeping my eyes off Kathleen Battle's sleeves, which would otherwise scramble my thought process, and I THINK I've got something I can work with now. It's seven syllables per line, or six syllables with the last-but-two in the line extended to almost take up two beats. Trochees for the first three feet, and the seventh syllable is stressed also. Phew. Life is hard for the tone-deaf!

Edited by Irritable1
  • Like 2
Link to comment

Here's mine.

 

It... got a little dark:o

 

Edit: and you know what, on looking it over, I see I pretty much abandoned meter. I'll need to take another shot at it.

 

Edit: Ok, I listened to the piece quite a number of times, carefully keeping my eyes off Kathleen Battle's sleeves, which would otherwise scramble my thought process, and I THINK I've got something I can work with now. It's seven syllables per line, or six syllables with the last-but-two in the line extended to almost take up two beats. Trochees for the first three feet, and the seventh syllable is stressed also. Phew. Life is hard for the tone-deaf!

Holy shit that sounds complicated. Why do I think I didn't take this serious enough now? Meter?

 

Edit: forgot an 'n'.

Edited by aditus
  • Like 2
Link to comment

 

 

Why do I think I didn't take this serious enough now? 

 

Sleeeeeeeeeeeeves?  :lol:

 

Let me see what I can do today, approaching it from the "angel" side and not the other....

 

Edit: Darn it! I was four lines in and doing great before I remembered about the rhymes  :angry:

Edited by Irritable1
  • Like 1
Link to comment

So it was a good thing the videos didn't work, no distracting sleeeeeeeves. For me it was all the numbers. Must be the natural scientist in me, or the math tutor or my great-great aunt. :huh:

  • Like 2
Link to comment

AUGH, I cannot work under these conditions :o I'm awarding myself an additional trochee per line.

 

Rhyme + meter = walking + chewing gum. Which I also can't do too well  :,(

Award away! Sit down and chew your gum; it's safer that way ;)

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Here's mine.

 

It... got a little dark:o

 

Edit: and you know what, on looking it over, I see I pretty much abandoned meter. I'll need to take another shot at it.

 

Edit: Ok, I listened to the piece quite a number of times, carefully keeping my eyes off Kathleen Battle's sleeves, which would otherwise scramble my thought process, and I THINK I've got something I can work with now. It's seven syllables per line, or six syllables with the last-but-two in the line extended to almost take up two beats. Trochees for the first three feet, and the seventh syllable is stressed also. Phew. Life is hard for the tone-deaf!

 

Yeah, Battle was channeling some 1980s fabulous with those sleeves.  Fill them with helium and see if she levitates!

  • Like 2
Link to comment

This one was a struggle.  My writing voice is too chirpy for such a somber sound.  I think I got the text tone to match the music.  

 

Reflection 

I was surprised to see both you and Irri doubt that the words fit the music. I went in with no preconceived notions - reading your lyrics and listening to the video - and found it worked really, really well. With music, the metre has to slide here and there and be equal to two beats, if the melody carries it that way. I was also impressed at how well the question mark ending one of the first lines matched the minor key modulation in the music - i think you did better than me at that particular juncture. Job well done!       

Done. And oy, is it sappy.

I for one do not find it to be 'sappy.' It seems true to life to me, and also very tender. I like it a lot 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Done. And oy, is it sappy.

William Shakespeare liked the poetical notion that a person's eyes casts out light onto what they see. The more sympathetic, he seemed to say, we look upon people, the more closely we can relate to what we see in them. I think that's akin to the idea you were trying to say in your reply to my review :)    

  • Like 1
Link to comment

As for Kathleen Battle's infamous 'balloon sleeves,' she was just obviously using them to push Flicka (the other singer) out of the limelight! Or, at least marginalize her to the periphery of the camera frame ; )

 

BTW, this was a Christmas concert at Carnegie Hall in 1991. Here's another sample – the number immediately after the Hansel and Gretel prayer song. For those of you who cannot open the links to youtube, can you let me know if you can watch it here as a preview window..? That would be a big help if I knew you could.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nChsp_KuCZQ

 

Gesú bambino, by Pietro A. Yon. Frederica von Stade, Kathleen Battle and the American Boys' Choir; André Previn conducts the Orchestra of Saint Luke's.  

Edited by AC Benus
Link to comment

William Shakespeare liked the poetical notion that a person's eyes casts out light onto what they see. The more sympathetic, he seemed to say, we look upon people, the more closely we can relate to what we see in them. I think that's akin to the idea you were trying to say in your reply to my review :)    

 

Thank you, that's a very warm and sweet way to look at it :) It was definitely what I was trying for.

Edited by Irritable1
  • Like 1
Link to comment

 

 For those of you who cannot open the links to youtube, can you let me know if you can watch it here as a preview window..? That would be a big help if I knew you could.

 

 

No, at least I can't open it. For this particular piece I could listen to Luciano Pavarotti's interpretation though. So, if it's only the music and not the artist, that would be okay, right? Or do I need to see the sleeeeves and that she lives up to her name and pushes others out of the limelight?
  • Like 1
Link to comment

 

 

No, at least I can't open it. For this particular piece I could listen to Luciano Pavarotti's interpretation though. So, if it's only the music and not the artist, that would be okay, right? Or do I need to see the sleeeeves and that she lives up to her name and pushes others out of the limelight?

 

Well, I just threw that vid in as a 'bonus,' and to see if GA would post it as they do in the blog entries. There it comes out as a preview window, and I was hoping you might be able to watch it if it appeared in that format.

 

Here is a great picture of Kathleen battling her power-wardrobe and pushing both Flicka and Wynton Marsalis to the edge of the camera frame! Haha - plz enjoy - http://www.amazon.com/Carnegie-Christmas-Frederica-Kathleen-Marsalis/dp/B000Q66PZW

Edited by AC Benus
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Our Privacy Policy can be found here: Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..