Maybe a weekly discussion question for the comment section to debate?

>What was everyone's favorite story this week? 

>Favorite line from a story this week (touching, funny, or simply awesome)?

No need to be have a different question every week. You can ask the same one over and over again.  Maybe have four, one for each week of every month. 

hmm.. me thinks the ol' boy is feeling the heat from his cheeky ways and is looking to turn over a new leaf so to speak. 

On a serious note though, I like the WWU, but if you feel that it needs a punching up or whatever, I like @astone2292's suggestions. If you're looking for a more in-depth discussion or whatever, prompting with a question could be what gets the ball rolling. It doesn't even have to be Writing, Reading, or anything. It could be current events, life updates, etc. If they're not too personal or nosey people may answer.  

@wildone -- as a reader, I like the way you have been doing the Weekly Wrap Ups.  However, @astone2292 has a good suggestion, should you decide to try some variations.  Questions might include what he listed, but with a cautionary note if the question might get into politics or subject matter that would run contrary to GA guidelines.  Possible questions could include Aaron's suggestions--

A--- What was everyone's favorite story this week?   
B--- Favorite line from a story this week (touching, funny, or simply awesome)?

I might also suggest --
C--- Which story you read in the past week has the most surprising plot twist?
D--- Which had your favorite one or two characters in it, and why (if that can be explained without giving the story away)?

Please keep up your good work.

And let me say that I'm delighted @Thirdly, @Krista, and @astone2292 took on some prompts.

@astone2292 idea of what was the readers fav book of the week is a good one, but requires too much work (for you). I'd keep it simple, change the book list, example:

On going story selection (random): 

1. Inherited by lomax61 "A very original contemporary mystery" (reader comment).

Stories have enough chapters that you don't need to list every on going story every week, but adding a comment is more interesting , takes readers to the book, and every book on the list of o going stories can get a mention, only not all in one go.

You could add: new stories this week and final chapters if you like and perhaps a completed story and review link and quote.

For me that's better than a bland list. The spotlight, Prompts, Ask an Author are self promoting and don't need repeat mentions unless there's some big change. The Goals stats are a waste of time, if you want stats put in site stats, numbers, countries, etc. of visitors. 

@wildone Well, you asked... I hope you don't have a job or something---

I like how you do things. The formatting is helpful to see what the week looks like. It’s easy to miss postings, especially in the blog sections. Sometimes my notifications get crazy and I don’t see stuff.

And I disagree that goal stats are a waste of time. I specifically look at those goal and then see where we’re low and go do those things. Need more story comments? I’m on it.

I also think Astones idea is great for an addition. I don’t see how his idea is more work for you. It’s more work for us, because we have to engage, which is the entire point.

I really don’t have any added suggestions but I think a fun question would be “what kind of story would you like to see/read?” Maybe someone has been waiting for a bank heist story or a hiking Everest meets near death experience.

It might get some juices flowing for authors.

You've basically followed what Renee did previously and I like it.  I check it out every week just to see if there was something I missed.  The ongoing scorecard gives us an overview of the site.